Well it sure is pretty, although the bright red ones like that are usually trouble. The meat test isn't a good test in my opinion because I'd have to throw out all my hermits and my emerald crab if I went by that. I think almost every crab out there is going to grab a free meat dinner if given the chance, you just want to stear clear of the ones that take things that aren't ready to be eaten.
If you have a sump, dump him in there until you get an ID. You could also closely monitor it to see its feeding and personality traits.