Help Me Pick A Cleaning Crew

kingspade

Member
what should i get for a cleaning cre for my 125 reef? this will be set up on wednesday or thursday with all the water from my semi established 125 non drilled i will also be using all my live rock from that tank as well, i have about 180+ lbs. how soon do i need to get a cleaning crew and what should it consist of?? also i am putting 240lbs of carib sea arag-alive bahama oolite sand in the tank that was not in my or any other previous tank the substrate is brand new.
 

kingspade

Member
whats your deal dude??? do you even own a tank or are you just a forum hoppin thread jacker?? go join a chat room somewhere and give them your incredible outlooks on saltwater tanks will ya??
 

reefiness

Active Member
Well with hermits i would say,
3 emerald crabs
1 lawnmower blenny
50 Nassarius Snails
50 Turbo/Astrea Snail
20 scarlet hermits
and a tiger tail cucumber(optional)
i think that should work. lets see what others have to think of that list
 

jamie814

Member
Originally Posted by reefiness
Well with hermits i would say,
3 emerald crabs
1 lawnmower blenny
50 Nassarius Snails
50 Turbo/Astrea Snail
20 scarlet hermits
and a tiger tail cucumber(optional)
i think that should work. lets see what others have to think of that list
I would not get the lawnmower yet they primary eat hair algea. Hence the name lawnmower - they mow it down.
I would not get that many Asteras espeially not turbos eaither, as far as hermits I would not get anything but the scarlet reef ones NO blue legged, red legged or zebra they have been know to attack snails for the sport of it. The electric blues and electric orange are complety peacefull and a good choice for variety and color but are kinda expensive at $7-$10 for one. For my 90 I'm going with the following from *********** dot com - truly free shipping there, This site is a joke when they say free shipping

25 Scarlet Reefs Crabs
6 Electric blue Crabs
6 Electric orange Crabs
1 Tongan fighting conch
16 Banded Trochus Snails (basically the same as astera's but nicer looking, larger and more effective)
12 Bumble Bee Snails (same as nassarius but neater looking)
6 Super Tongan Nassarius Snails (large version of nassarius)
No emeralds for now had 6 of them in my last tank and they all seemed to kick the bucket right away
 

reefiness

Active Member
i was talking about turbo/astrea snails on salt water. they're not mexican turbos like i think you are thinking of. the scarlets i have are the same ones that you are talking about.
 

jamie814

Member
Originally Posted by reefiness
i was talking about turbo/astrea snails on salt water. they're not mexican turbos like i think you are thinking of. the scarlets i have are the same ones that you are talking about.
yea the mexican turbos are the big ones that need lots of algea to survive and I would not recomend that many of them.
 

wax32

Active Member

Originally Posted by jamie814
12 Bumble Bee Snails (same as nassarius but neater looking)

Not true
.
They are generally carnivores like most snails in the whelk family. They are usually pretty harmless in a reef tank, BUT they are nowhere near the same as a Nassarius snail, and won't touch the sand bed, which is what Nassarius snails are for.
I'd for sure cut back on the Astraea snails, that many will starve, especially right at first. You can always add more later.
I'd go:
20 Astraea
, 5 Trochus
, 12 Nassarius
, 20 hermits of your choice and 1 emerald crab to start. You can always add more. You don't want them to starve in your new tank.
 

jamie814

Member

Originally Posted by wax32
Not true
.
They are generally carnivores like most snails in the whelk family. They are usually pretty harmless in a reef tank, BUT they are nowhere near the same as a Nassarius snail, and won't touch the sand bed, which is what Nassarius snails are for.
I'd for sure cut back on the Astraea snails, that many will starve, especially right at first. You can always add more later.
I'd go:
20 Astraea
, 5 Trochus
, 12 Nassarius
, 20 hermits of your choice and 1 emerald crab to start. You can always add more. You don't want them to starve in your new tank.
Do you have these and they don't go in the sand :notsure: Becasue the ones that I have burry in the sand, also here is the discription from the website that I got them,
The Bumble Bee Snail is a distinctly small snail with yellowish bands on a dark brown background.
It is a beneficial snail to have in the aquarium, and will do well if provided with ample hiding places and room to roam. It prefers an aquarium with live rock so that it can graze on uneaten meety foods and detritus. It is also a sand sifter so prefers an aquarium with a deep sand bed in which to forage. It requires high water quality and is sensitive to high levels of copper-based medications and will not tolerate high nitrate levels.
 

wax32

Active Member
Mine don't touch the sand, they stay in the rocks. There are LOTS of species of snail called "bumblebee" snails. That's why common names suck.
 

dexter

Member
This is the Cleaning crew I have for my 100 gallon.

35-40 turbo astro snails
15 nassarius snails
80-100+ hermits (blus, scarlet, grey legged)
2 brittle stars
1 peppermint shrimp(need 2 more)
1 camelback shrimp
2 coral banded shrimp
8-10 emerald crabs (need 2 more)
2 sally lightfoot
1 cleaner shrimp
1 queen conch
2 sand sifting cucumbers (1 lg, 1 small)
Dxtr -
 
Top