How many snails?

michael7979

Member
I'm going to change from sand sifting stars to snails(cerith and/or nassarius). I have a 55 with approx. 3 inches of sand. I have no idea though how many of each or total I should get? Please give me your ideas and comments. Thanks in advance.
 
I dont know a whole lot about this exactly(probably explains my algae problem) but i'll bump this for you with a little bit of what I think
I think you should have atleast 10 snails, no matter the tank size. what I do is check out those cleaner packages on swf.com and look at how many come in that for my tank size and then just add a few. for example if they have 20 snails... get about 25. just some thoughts hth
 

michael7979

Member
Guess I should list what I have now . About 10 bumble bee snails(not big sand stirrers), about 12 hermits , a sally lf ,along with ablenny ,2 gobies ,and a gs maroon.
 

michael7979

Member
Some one out there has to have some idea . Please help I would like to place an order a.s.a.p. but I need advice!!!!!!
 
K

kpatrick

Guest
from what I saw in your posting you dont have anything that can clean the algea off your glass. If your glass is getting algea you need to look inot astrea, nas, and turbo snails. IF it were me and I was having an algea problem I would get at least a dozen of each of them. keep in mind the the mexican turbo grazers dont seem to live as long as the astrea and nas. but they eat a lot more algea. you could even try some emerald crabs and scarlet hermits to help with the algea!
On the flip side you dont want to get to carried away because once the algea is gone the snails may starve.
 

michael7979

Member
I'm seeing that now because my LMB is keeping the glass very clean . My bigger problem is stirring up the sand. I have hermits and BB snails. Looking for who will stir the most sand.
 

reefpunk

New Member
i think the sand shifter would do a good job or did you already get rid of it.
Why did you wont thre sand shifter in your tank anymore?
 

michael7979

Member
Alot of people on this board have said that a sandsifting star will at some point kill the good part of the living sand (don't want that to happen) and the star is almost always hiding. Its to the point that I don't want it knock anything over also.
 

jbstuart

Member
I have 12 tequil turbo snails & 20 astrea snails, so far in the months the only one i've lost got trapped between some rocks. I've got a huge order of Nass snails coming actually 50 which is way to many but I couldn't pass up the real good deal. I'll just put some in all my aquariums. Nass snails I've been told eat detrius matter, and can potentially replace hermits. I like this idea personally due to my hermits enjoy killing my snails for their shells.
Thanks
Jarod
 

michael7979

Member
So JB you say 50 is to much for your 100+ tank is that because you already have some or is that too much period. I have a 55 so do you think 10 would be cool.?
 

jbstuart

Member
Post 100!
I'm no snail expert, and there is no exact science to how many to have. It all depends on the amount of food you have in your tank. One person may have a huge hair algea problem, and another have a diantom problem. Both of these can call for different kinds of clean up crew. My suggestion is to have a variety of several types. Astrea, turbos, nass, cerith, ect. Personally I would think 10 would be real good for your sand bed. Most people get nass snails to their sand bed top layer is worked. The only other suggestion I would have is if you dont have much algea, stop cleaning the back and one side of your tank until you can determine with a reasonable accurancy that you have enough for them to eat. Otherwise, you'll have some dead snails, which equates to a few ugly shells. (nass snails are not that attractive). Another piece of advice is to pay attention to the latin name, some places advertise nass snails but dont really ship them. Nassarius Vibex is a latin name for them.
good luck
To answer your question on quantity. I think 50 is way to many. I plan to add them all though and see what happens.
 
Top