Um Francis,
You did a 100% water change? Meaning you took ALL the water out and replaced it after cycling it.
DId you use fresh seawater then too?
OK, First, Did you see the ammonia spike go up then go down to nothing?
think I know what you mean you only filled it 3/4 the way. You did that so the other 1/4 would be the top off??
Okay, Then... Lets do this. Go to the fish store and buy a bag of salt.. Mix it up to the salinity you are at.. should be between 1.022-1.025.. which ever you want. Let it sit a day with a thermometer in it and a powerhead. THEN, your gonna fill the tank to the top. ~ Retest it.
Never remove 100% of the water again because that's all the "good " bacteria you built up while cycling. YOur tank MIGHT have another mini cycle. DId you use Live Sand when you set up this tank?
If after a week you dont see ANY ammonia OR NitrITES, you should be OK. Then check your NitRATES... can run between 0-40.. 40 would be on the high side but still acceptable. I expect you shouldnt see a 40 or higher on such a new tank but, you never know becuase of the natural seawater.
Then, for now on..... only ADD fresh ro/di water OR treated Tap water for "top off", which is from EVAPORATION. When you do your small weekly OR larger monthly water changes(WHICH EVER IS BETTER FOR YOUR TANK) your gonna mix the store saltwater and take out the same amount of gallons your gonna change and replace it with the saltwater mix.
Please feel free to ASK questions here... We are Only here to help. Also, do you have any books on saltwater tanks? I bought a couple before I began this hobby.. Believe it or not "saltwaterfish for dummies" is a pretty good book.
As far as stocking, what kind of anenome's do you have? In a 35G.. 3 might be too many. They may shoot darts "meaning STING" each other and die. Also, LIGHTS are very important when keeping CORALS. So please tell me about your LIGHTING. Maybe I can HELP you out there, if you want to keep your corals ALIVE. NO problem! You can get proper lighting for your tank.
Hope this helps, Kim