HOW TO KILL PISTOL SHRIMP

scrawny

New Member
Hi i was wondering if there is anyway or any fish that i could buy to rid my tank of pistol shrimp as they are noisy and a pain in the butt at night i know they r good for my tank but i realy want some sleep
can anyone offer me suggestions?????
thanks
 

jakob4001

Member
you could try to bait it out into a 20 oz plastic coke bottle w/ some food; best if opening is placed nearest it's known location; don't kill it though; trade back to LFS or maybe a local fellow hobbysist; someone w/ a watchman goby might want it or simply remove thr LR that you know it's in & place in tub then carefully scoop it out when it comes out
 

von_rahvin

Member
welcome to the board. I would agree that baiting them out is the way to go. if you leave the botle or container near the hole for a few day and then do it you should have more success.
 

cadbury

Member
Not to change the subject but would the Pistol Shrimp have the same relationship with a Blue Spotted Jawfish as they would with a Watchman Goby?
 
I have read the the Watchman Goby may become more reclusive when paired with a shrip. Can anyone confirm or deny this? Also curious on how the pistol shrimp is "noisy"??
 

volitan

Member
Pistol shrimp snap their claws shut hardand it makes a bang. It's pretty loud, thus the name pistol shrimp. Maybe someone else can tell us why they do it.
 

cadbury

Member
Found some info for you, hope this helps:
The Pistol Shrimp may also be called Symbiosis Shrimp and Snapping Shrimp. It is found in a variety of colors and sizes. Pistol Shrimp are not easily sexed, but the males of many species are thought to have a larger pincher. The sound it makes comes from an appendage on the pincher which moves when the pincher is opened or closed and water is ejected. The Pistol Shrimp can be easily confused with Mantis Shrimp if judged by sound only. Unlike the Mantis Shrimp, it is not harmful and will not pose any threat in the tank, with the possible exception of smaller shrimp.
The name Symbiotic Shrimp comes from the equally beneficial relationship the Pistol Shrimp has with gobies (e.g.;Amblyeleotris or Stenogobius). The goby, with better eyesight, warns the shrimp of predators. The shrimp share its food with the goby. Depending upon the species, Pistol Shrimp may also have symbiotic relationships with sponges, corals, or anemones (e.g.; Bartholomea annulata).
It is beneficial to the tank as it churns the sand. It thrives in environments with sand, rock caves, and dim light. If in pairs, one will often stand guard at the burrow while the other is inside. The Pistol Shrimp are intolerant of copper or high nitrate levels, but need a correct level of iodine in the water to promote proper molting.
Pistol Shrimp will accept freeze-dried and frozen foods and bottom feeder tablets. The Pistol Shrimp are intolerant of copper or high nitrate levels, but need a correct level of iodine in the water to promote proper molting.
 

kris walker

Active Member
I would kill the buggers too if they were purposefully trying to keep me up at night. Everyone knows they don't do that in nature from where we took them. Jerk shrimp. :)
kris
 

scrawny

New Member
well i have managed to locate them they live beneath the rocks not in them and as soon as i shine my tourch on them they disapear so it is gonna be hard to get them
so no one knows of a fish or another shrimp that will kill these little devil shrimp they r so noisy
 

treble

Member
I dont think there is a fish that could kill em, thats not reef safe. You tear down the LR and get em, place food in a 2 liter bottle washed out, or a milk jug underwater, then wait for them to go into it, have to cap on hand and shut it up and take the LFS and get store credit.
 

scrawny

New Member
u mthey dont have to be reef safe just prey on shrip like hawkfish or sumfin like that
and have to get along with community fish like clowns and damsels thats all
hope this helps
i have tried the bottle thing too
they r too smart and wont even go near it
:mad: <img src="graemlins//yell.gif" border="0" alt="[yell]" />
 

symon

Member
Hmmm I never noticed this until yesterday, Hearing clicks in the tank, Although i have been trying to hear it now, and i get 1 maybe 2 clicks at a time, Not multipul as if it where a mantis , also no fish have come up missing!
 

nm reef

Active Member
This thread was dug up from the archives!!!
In regard to hearing a clicking sound....the source could be any of a number of things.....not only a pistol....I've had snails make the same type sounds when too close to a power head.....if there is a pistol or mantis there will normally be indications other than "sound" of its presence. Both pistols I keep are constantly making tunnels under the LR structures and the sign of their digging is easily identified. Possibly check at night to see signs of movement......and if it is a pistol the damage shouldn't be enough to cause major concern....in my opinion they can be very nice additions...and the noise mine make is rarely enough to concern me.
 

mad dog 21

New Member
Originally Posted by brianwadep
Pistol shrimp snap their claws shut hardand it makes a bang. It's pretty loud, thus the name pistol shrimp. Maybe someone else can tell us why they do it.
Pistol shrimp snap their larger claw closed to send out a shock wave to stun their prey, such as small fish and shrimp. It's one of the fastest movements in the animal kingdom. I was watching the Discovery channel and they said that they compress the water between their pincers so fast that for a brief instant it gets as hot as the surface of the sun. Pretty crazy stuff. I saw a video of a larger pistol shrimp stunning a cleaner shrimp. One click and the cleaner was down for the count. Always made me worry that they might get aggressive in the aquarium and go after other shrimp and slow-moving fish.
 

mad dog 21

New Member
Originally Posted by Symon
well i found the noise maker, my darn gobies spittin rocks against the side of the tank!
That's really funny. Any chance you could get some video footage of that?
 
Top