I added one new fish (Royal Gramma) about 3 days before this started showing up, acclimated by drip 1 1/2 hours, it just seems I can't get away from this ick, tank went for 4 weeks with no fish, did a 50% water change, I get my water tested at LFS every week all levels are perfect, I did a dip strip test also after every application of Stop Parasite and everything shows ideal. I just don't know, I am hoping the Stop Parasite will cure this constant problem. And yes all the fish are new as of Saturday prior to last with the exception of the Gramma which I got the following day. Yes I saw all of them eat, they are all eating fine now too except the small PJ.
I have
2 flame scallops
3 Anenome
6 blue leg hermits
1 coral banded
1 generic hermit
12 turbo snails
1 sand sifting star
1 chocolate chip star
1 percula
2 PJ cardinals
1 blue devil damsel
1 Royal Gramma
Damsel is clean
Percula is clean