Is my LFS Correct?

[meemmoo]

I just got back from my LFS that is strictly a SWA dealer and I was getting things for my new 50g tank. She said I did not need a filter cause the LR and LS act as a filter. Just about everyone in this forum I believe has some sort of filter or sump. Am I just confused or is she wrong?

 

[jacknjill]

you dont have to have a filter. but it comes in very handy to run carbon and add more circulation to your tank

 

[sammiefish]

yeah, I would be mainly concerned with running a protein skimmer...
your LR and LS will metabolize ammonia waste ...
i would only use a power filter occasionally to (like jnj said) run carbon etc.
Get a protein skimmer before you get a power or canister filter...

 

[meemmoo]

what do you reccommend for a protein skimmer for a 50g?

 

[jacknjill]

for my 55 i have a CPR Bak Pak 2 and it works great

 

[gootz]

My only question is how much lr and ls do you have?? IMO if your not going to run a filter you should have 1-2 pounds of lr per gallon

 

[joker_ca]

you really dont need a filter just a good skimmer and plenty of water movement, all you need to have is a good amount of LR and a DSB and thats about it

 

[mbrands]

Originally posted by meemmoo
what do you reccommend for a protein skimmer for a 50g?
AquaC Remora is hands down the best for that size tank. I love mine!