as far as i know any cuke can nuke your tank. I love the way that sounds. anyways back on topic, the lettuce nudi is a great addition if you have plenty of algae for it and you can keep it out of your power heads and intakes. They almost always seem to get into them anyways, at which point its like running a grape through a strainer. I would see if your system can be made safe for them, and wait for someone else to post, but that is my unprofessional opinion, since i have not kept either species.