Just curious - I thought pretty much anything porus that was in a tank with LR would become "live" - since live rock is called live rock due to the bacteria growth rather then actual visible livestock.
I figured the reason the majority use actual base rock is not because of it's ability to go "live" but rather that base rock is going to be marine compatible and not leach nutrients and other bad things into the tank, like lava rock does.
So with that said - I have 70lbs of LR, and about 15-20lbs of dead coral skeletons, tank has been running for almost a year, wouldn't my coral skeletons be considered "live" at this point, since the bacteria have likely colonized on it and are acting as a biofliter?