looking for a rare fish

blue strip

Member
i want to get a rare fish to put in my tank nothing crazy but something most household tanks wont have any ideas all yeah i got a 120
 

xdave

Active Member
What else you planning on keeping, or are you gonna decide that one based onwhat would go with the rare one?
IMHO
This may sound like smart *ss answer but, the rarist thing I ever see is a fish that had room to grow to show size. Most people get a 120 and cram it with fish and they never get an impressive size. If you only get 3 babies that have a large adult size, it may look silly now, but in a year or so it will blow everyone away. Did you ever see a 12" Sailfin Tang? How about a school of 5" Hawaiin Snowflake Damsels, spectacular.
Heres what I would do if I wanted a 120 that looked like no other. First I'd get a Threadfin butterfly. 2 months later a Sailfin or Chevron Tang a little smaller than him. 2 months later I'd get 3 Hawaiin Snowflake Damsels. Then in about 1 month I'd get a juvi net caught Red Sea Pomacanthus angel, a Queen or an Imperator are my favorites. Not a lot of fish but they will get to a size and beauty that is truly rare in the hobby nowadays.
 

yupi1982

Member
your opinion is very interesting XDAVE i bet most people never thought about that!!!
you made a great point in this hobby!!!

and yeahhhhh to see developing a fish is the most spectacular thing...

we will be blown to see a 12 show size angel!!!
 

xdave

Active Member
case in point: An LFS owner was at my house looking at my reef tank, he said " wow, that big red and black fish is spectacular, what is it?" I said " what, you've never seen a Tomato Clown before?"!!!
 

durgeonman

Member
Originally Posted by xDave
case in point: An LFS owner was at my house looking at my reef tank, he said " wow, that big red and black fish is spectacular, what is it?" I said " what, you've never seen a Tomato Clown before?"!!!

please tell me your kidding, that is one of the funniest things i have ever heard
 

yupi1982

Member
Originally Posted by xDave
case in point: An LFS owner was at my house looking at my reef tank, he said " wow, that big red and black fish is spectacular, what is it?" I said " what, you've never seen a Tomato Clown before?"!!!
I am looking forward to see some pics of your reef and that huge tomato !!! ***)
 

yupi1982

Member
Originally Posted by xDave
She died 7 years ago at around 11 years old.
sorry to hear that!!!
could you show me some pics of your actual reef :jumping:
 

xdave

Active Member
I'm afraid I dont have anything right now. I'm unemployed and am living with a relative. Never really took any fish pics. I did find a couple.
this is my volitans baby picture. He won 2nd or 3rd (whatever the red dot means, blue is 1st). marine fish at only 5" when a volitan would have to be over 10" to be considered show size. He was in the ocean 8 days earlier. Love those Red Sea fish.
My baby Volitan
This is my unmedicated rescue tank.
the rescue tank
I would bring home hard luck cases and fix them up.
In there you see a Yellow Tang that was still in shock 2 days after he came in, a Pakistani Butterfly that was just wailing on any fish in sight, and a Flame Angel that was just so little he got picked on a lot. The tang went back to work after a couple weeks, the Pakistani went to the zoo after a year, the Flame I kept for about 10 years. My daughter put some of my smaller trophies next to them so that they'd know that not only would they be ok but they would grow up to be the prettiest fish ever. I'm still looking around, I must at least have some other show pictures.
 

xdave

Active Member
A fish that is considered rare in the aquarium hobby fits into a couple of catagories.
*Fish that dont travel well. Although possibly suited to tank life, they just dont survive long enough to get there.
*Fish that have too specific of a diet or care requirements. these get to the store but starve within a week. The "assorted butterfly" tank at the LFS is a good place to see these. A Trifaciatus butterfly is easy to catch and ship but very difficult to maintain for even a couple weeks.
*The following scenario I can only vouche for how it went where I worked and may or may not be the case anywhere else.
The rare fish you really want, well heres the story, they are lost to "DIBS!!!". Almost everyone that works at a distributor is an extreme hobbyist. A rare specimen is immediately purchased by them. Half the time they are shipped in error as a common species. If that doesn't happen the zoo gets next pick because they come before opening time, if they dont want them, the store owners put them in one of their tanks at home, or grabs him for that guy he knows.
 

clown boy

Active Member
Originally Posted by yupi1982
we will be blown to see a 12 show size angel!!!
I saw one once. I almost fainted! :scared:
 

blizz75

Member
The problem with a 120 is that most of the fish u suggested dave, will outgrow it. There are not many large fish that will fit into a 120. Its only a 4' tank, if ur talking about a standard one. Just look at this site and tho considered common in the trade there are tons of fish that not to many people keep.
But that brings up the prob. dave mentioned, most Rare fish or not commonly kept fish are that because they are hard to keep and take alot of care and time.
 

xdave

Active Member
I was thinking of a 125, whats a 120, Is that like a 110 only even taller? That would be like a picture window. I'd be afraid it would fall over.
 
N

nereef

Guest
how about a yellow tang that doesn't look like crap; that would be rare.
 

cgrant

Active Member
Originally Posted by blue strip
i want to get a rare fish to put in my tank nothing crazy but something most household tanks wont have any ideas all yeah i got a 120
depends on what you plan on doing? reef or fowlr?
I have a 9" golden puffer, dont see alot of those!
 

sw65galma

Active Member
a school of anthias.
I like rare fish myself...keeping an Idol and now a Hawaiian dragon moray eel...
Anyway if this is your first tank...DON'T
If it's not, then Almost any fish will impress the average person.
Tank of triggers is an awsome sight for visitors.
 
Top