Need help, it seems my green bristle star eating my fish

jjokcca

New Member
I have 3 bristle star and it seems I am missing a percula crown so often, I did some research on this green bristle star, and got some info that i cannot believe. Is really bristle star will catch small fish?
if so then I guess I need to arrange something with my LFS to get trade for the stars.
Can anybody help?
 
H

hurley

Guest
Bristle stars will catch and eat small fish. If one of your stars is really fat compared to the other 2 you know were your perc is at. Sorry for your loss in anycase. I loss alot of fish & inverts when I first started this ( addiction ) opps I ment hobbie :D . a very costly learning experiance.
 

jjokcca

New Member
Thanks
I guess I should trade in my my stars. it seem all three are pretty fat looks like. star was great clean up crew, but i guess I need to do something about this. does anyone know star that won't eat small fish?
 

iechy

Member
The green ones are known for doing that. If you still want a brittle star to clean up you can get a brown/black one. They aren't known to eat fish so much. I have two and haven't had any trouble.
 
H

hurley

Guest
Elegant star but from what I know is that most star fish can be destructive to inverts etc. but if you feed your stars (clam meat, dead fish or shrimp ) they might not go after your smaller fish.
 

sistrmary

Member
Linckias are pretty and fairly reef safe. They're a bit high priced, but worth it IMO My purple linkia is one of my favorite things to watch when its out.
 

ophiura

Active Member
Because of their diets, all Linckia need to be in large mature reef tanks with a lot of LR, and there should not be more than one unless the system is very large (over 100g). The do not feed on detritus and are not part of a clean up crew. They feed on microbial and algal films, as well as other encrusting animals like sponges and bryozoans. If they are not in a suitable system, they will tend to starve, a process that takes months up to a year.
The purple Linckia, as it is often called, is not typically a Linckia. If it has orange tube feet, it is a star called Tamaria stria, and potentially not reef safe by some accounts.
All species of Linckia
and the similar Fromia
(elegant star) are very delicate, and need to be drip acclimated for many hours, at every step of their transport. I recommend this for all echinoderms (seastars, urchins, cucumbers, brittle/serpentstars).
Most other species of brittle or serpentstars are not known to be predatory. However, they should all be spot fed and not allowed to scavenge. They will eat if they are hungry. The green brittlestar is a known predator in the wild, and should never be sold simply as a clean up crew. Most species of brittle/serpents are hardier than Linckia
and better suited to smaller and/or younger systems.
 

ddaddy

Member
I have had some nasty experiences with my green brittle star too. He ate about 20X his worth in fish and inverts. I HAD a cute yellow watchman goby but it just turned out to be a $40 starfish snack. Not to mention a sally lightfoot crab, a bunch of hermits and amazingly enough a condy anemone.
I can't say it was a total loss though. I took him to a real crappy fish store that has sold me nothing but grief in bad livestock and advice. The owner thought she got the best of me when she said she didn't accept credit on livestock... then she dropped him in a tank full of clowns. :D :p :D
 

fishtanker

Member
i wouldn't advise on a cc star either i had the same experiences with them.
Question:
does anyone know if u could put a Linckia star in a 55gal with 40-50 lbs of LR. I kinda like the blue ones.
 

ophiura

Active Member
Linckia has a poor shipping record and must be drip acclimated for 6-8 hours at each step of the way. Be sure to do this and hope. IMO, your tank is too small and does not have enoough live rock. These guys will not take food like shrimp pellets, and rely entirely on LR for food (bacterial and algal film, sponges and bryozoans). The tank should be quite mature (absolute minimum 6 months). At least a year old is better...
Anyway, it is risky, IMO. Survival rate is low and the best shot is in a larger tank.
 

fishtanker

Member

Originally posted by ophiura
Linckia
has a poor shipping record and must be drip acclimated for 6-8 hours at each step of the way. Be sure to do this and hope. IMO, your tank is too small and does not have enoough live rock. These guys will not take food like shrimp pellets, and rely entirely on LR for food (bacterial and algal film, sponges and bryozoans). The tank should be quite mature (absolute minimum 6 months). At least a year old is better...
Anyway, it is risky, IMO. Survival rate is low and the best shot is in a larger tank.

thanks ophiura, i here u are the sh** when it comes to stars'. i'm looking for a reef safe star, i have a sand sifting that i never see, i don't really like the brittle or serpant stars i'm wondering if there are any other choices out there. how big do red general stars get?
 
Top