New 90 Gallon Tank, my first time with Saltwater!

chaosfyre

Member
OK, I didn't know we couldn't post other sites. I guess I should hunt down the rules.
I know what Ich is and cleaner shrimp and all that; I did say I researched for a couple years. Plus, freshwater fish can get ich too, and I've always had lots of freshwater fish. I've had a couple cases of ich, though very rare, and its always on a new fish that had it coming in. It never spread in my system though, and I never had to quarantine my fish to kill it. A tiny dose of aquarium salt in a freshwater tank is good for most freshwater fish (though I wouldn't recommend it for betas) and keeps likelihood of diseases down. The stress coat stuff helps them stay healthy too even if they get stressed, and I always dose my tap for freshwater aquariums with stress coat/conditioner.
I do have a 10 gal tank with salt water in it to be used for quarantine, breeder, or refugium, eventually. I was planning on raising pods and brine shrimp in it to seed my tank with, but I need some live sand in it first. I have a handful of empty tanks lying around that I should hunt down. Since saltwater fish are so much more expensive than freshwater, I will probably be quarantining anything I get from now on.
So yeah, the experience of caring for pets has prepared me for dealing with salt-water... Its pretty easy if you aren't lazy and clean your glass regularly, replace the water, do the changes, measure the salinity and test regularly, and do a lot of research about the compatability of creatures before you add them to the tank. And as always, when in doubt, google. Some people say it is a lot of work, but I'm used to taking lots of time out of my day to care for critters, and I enjoy doing so. My family has some acreage, and I remember one memorable time when I counted over 50 animals...
My boyfriend thinks it is too much work having 2 dogs. =P Hah!
 

chaosfyre

Member
@pattenie:
Thanks for the links to the books. So, am I allowed to post links from other sites, just not from sites that might compete with this one? I.E., sites that sell fish?
 
P

pattenie

Guest
I THINK I SENT THAT ONE TO YOU ALREADY MY BAD WELL GOOD LUCK ON YOUR TANK ITS A LOT OF FUN
 

flower

Well-Known Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by ChaosFyre http:///t/394244/new-90-gallon-tank-my-first-time-with-saltwater/20#post_3508974
OK, I didn't know we couldn't post other sites. I guess I should hunt down the rules.
I know what Ich is and cleaner shrimp and all that; I did say I researched for a couple years. Plus, freshwater fish can get ich too, and I've always had lots of freshwater fish. I've had a couple cases of ich, though very rare, and its always on a new fish that had it coming in. It never spread in my system though, and I never had to quarantine my fish to kill it. A tiny dose of aquarium salt in a freshwater tank is good for most freshwater fish (though I wouldn't recommend it for betas) and keeps likelihood of diseases down. The stress coat stuff helps them stay healthy too even if they get stressed, and I always dose my tap for freshwater aquariums with stress coat/conditioner.
I do have a 10 gal tank with salt water in it to be used for quarantine, breeder, or refugium, eventually. I was planning on raising pods and brine shrimp in it to seed my tank with, but I need some live sand in it first. I have a handful of empty tanks lying around that I should hunt down. Since saltwater fish are so much more expensive than freshwater, I will probably be quarantining anything I get from now on.
So yeah, the experience of caring for pets has prepared me for dealing with salt-water... Its pretty easy if you aren't lazy and clean your glass regularly, replace the water, do the changes, measure the salinity and test regularly, and do a lot of research about the compatability of creatures before you add them to the tank. And as always, when in doubt, google. Some people say it is a lot of work, but I'm used to taking lots of time out of my day to care for critters, and I enjoy doing so. My family has some acreage, and I remember one memorable time when I counted over 50 animals...
My boyfriend thinks it is too much work having 2 dogs. =P Hah!
Any fish site is not allowed, along with dirty talk and fighting. It's not a big deal, and I think every one of us has found out about the no posting other site rules just like you did. We did it, and somebody informed us it wasn't allowed.
Freshwater ich and saltwater ich are two very different critters...LOL, you can't add a little salt to a saltwater tank to get rid of it. With freshwater ich you can add medicine right to the display, and clear the tank of the parasite and a host of other problems. In saltwater, the medicine would kill the inverts and critters that live in the substrate and rock...so you have to move the fish to another tank to treat them, and leave the tank without fish so the parasite dies without a host...6 to 8 weeks. So you can't treat illness in the display tank ever, no matter what the disease. Also in saltwater tanks, other critters eat the sick and dying....so a weak fish would be doomed if not moved where it can recover in peace.
Quarantine is the best thing you could do, an ounce of prevention really counts in this hobby, and I'm glad to hear that's your plan.

p>
Raising copepods and amphipods are easy, just seed the tank, (acclimate them just like you do fish to keep them healthy to breed, if you want to just feed the fish, just dump them in) brine shrimp however is not doable. You can feed live brine shrimp, (not as the only food of course) but you have to hatch them outside of the display. www.wikihow.com/Raise-Brine
-Shrimp
http://www.wikihow.com/Raise-Brine-Shrimp
Now, I want to say a little something:
I kept freshwater fish for over 30 years, and saltwater reefs for over 10. Right now I have 2 tanks, a 90g with Potbelly seahorses, and the other is a 56g tall tank with Kuda seahorses. I read up on saltwater tanks for about 8 years before I could actually start. I had small children, and even though I loved SW tanks, I just didn't have the cash to spend, so I stayed with freshwater fish that I had been keeping since I was a young girl. (the hobby is not as expensive now as back then...it was called the rich mans hobby) Then after they my kids were grown I finally did it (age 40)...and I found out as time went that didn't know anything really until I got my own SW tank...After a few years, I thought I had a pretty good handle on it, and then I found this site. I have discovered much better ways to do things. The people on this site have much more hands on experience than any book could ever hope to offer, the web didn't exist when I started, and I relied on the LFS advice (*****) and books....You couldn't pay me enough to go to ***** now for anything, except to buy media for my filter...that includes what they sell as test kits. You argued about purchasing the test kit, instead you tell me your plan is to run to ***** to do your tests (it's only 5 min away) and when they say "it's all good" you think it is. You have no idea what the numbers are. That isn't so bad until something goes wrong, and to help you, we will need those numbers, not just right then, but what they were leading up to whatever disaster is happening.
Dealing with the time and money to properly care for pets is great...I have you beat on the animal thing as well...the perk of being almost 3Xs your age. LOL..reading up for two years is commendable, ...please trust me, you have no idea. You should not argue to keep your point of view so much....be flexible, and ask more questions on the why, such as what GeriDoc tried to tell you. He had a ton of knowledge to share with you, but you are not ready to listen yet.
What you have been doing so far isn't bad, nothing is dead, so far so good...LOL...there is just a better way, and maybe three or four better methods to try. What you read on the ad for stresscoat, and on the label, naturally is going to make the stuff sound like the best thing since baked bread. Unless you are an expert on marine biology, you can learn a few things.
We know what tap water does... because we have done it, stresscoat and all...and found out the hard way how great it really is...looks like you will be joining us from the school of hard knocks down the road, don't worry...we will still be here to tell what you can do to get rid of all the hair algae.
 

acrylic51

Active Member
I reread through the posts and must have missed something.....I will jump in on something and it rather frustrates me at times on this site....I seen a mention of CUC......There is no fast dead set answer as to what is needed....That is totally dependent somewhat on how your system is setup and running.....With that said 100 snails in a 90 gallon.........
Totally wrong and overkill......Not enough space for 100 snails, lets be realistic with this guys.......
 

chaosfyre

Member
@pattenie: Thanks!
@acrylic: Yes, 100 in 90 gallons is too many. Plus, the hermit crabs only kill snails when they need shells, and there are only 3 crabs, and I raised land hermit crabs for years so I've got plenty of the good kind of shells for them. I dropped them all in and they are loving it. Someday I'll get a bit more on the cleanup kit, but right now they would starve unless its something that eats diatoms.
@Flower: I read more than just one person's opinion before I make my decision. You do not have to push your particular opinion so hard. You do realize there are hundreds of people on the site who disagree with some of the things you say? It is not all set in stone, there are a lot of ways of doing things. A lot of the things you are warning me about, I have already read other people's opinions on (like the tap water). I know the difference between freshwater and saltwater ich. You should read the link I posted about it, there are some tips on treated saltwater ich without using meds (more than just the tips I mentioned).
Also, there are a lot of filtration options that get rid of tap water impurities, but the people around here have had saltwater tanks for years using tap without algae problems. It really depends on your local water quality. If algae grows, it is not that big of a deal. If it happens, it happens. I don't even have any corals right now, and I plan on getting a dwarf angel that will eat algae, and there are lots of ways to kill algae that I've already researched, so... I'm not going to cry if some algae starts growing in my tank.
I am on a VERY tight budget right now, so it is not so much that I am unwilling to listen, but I will use what is available to me and what I can afford. No matter how much you push me to buy test kits and RO unit, etc, its just not going to happen unless I stumble across hidden treasure. My tank will not be magazine pretty for some years anyway.
As for the *****, every store is different. Mine has about 5 saltwater reef guys just like the people on this site. Some of them are even in the local saltwater club with me. I have gotten to know a few of them on a personal basis, so please don't rag on them. They take very good care of the fish at "their" store, and so far nothing they have told me has been wrong (I always do the research myself, even if they recommend something). And yes, at the store they gave me numbers for the kits. I watched them test it myself, and looked at the results. Its just like the stuff we use in the lab, and in the lab we have to be very precise, so I don't see what the problem is. Their kit, my kit, what does it matter? Because they are only 5 minutes away, its basically like walking into the kitchen and grabbing a test strip.
Believe me though, I have wished for a specialized saltwater store closer to me. The closest one is 2 hours away, and the next closest one is 3 hours. I've been to both on many occasions over the years, but its just not practical. It costs me $40 or more in gas just to get down there. So, ***** it is. Everything else I order online.
 

flower

Well-Known Member
It took me 5 minutes to find where I said 100 snails...but I found it, and I did post that. Over time I have put at least a hundred snails in my 90g, but the way I posted it, sounds like they were dumped all at once, and what I was saying to do. I love this site because if one person misdirects it's caught before it does any harm. Mostly I had intended to comment on one lone snail in a group of hermits...but you said you didn't have anything for the snail to eat and was waiting on the CUC, which is smart.. A clean up crew is a combination of whatever cleaning critters a person wants. Serpent stars, hermits, snails, even fan worms, even clams. I also stated quite clearly that you can do tapwater and if you are careful to do your water changes, you shouldn't have problems. ...I'm done, obviously you don't need advice, you have it all under control.
P.S.
That doesn't mean you can't just post and talk...pictures are always welcome. I apologize if I sounded pushy on my opinions...I honestly always think I'm not understood and repeat myself. I won't offer anymore advice unless you ask for it.
 

acrylic51

Active Member
Flower that's how I read your post in regards to snails......I do see it recommended here though about ungodly amounts of snails and stuff for tanks......
 

sweatervest13

Active Member
Congrats on the new tank. A 90g with all that equipment for $200.00 is a great deal.
Quote:
Plus, the hermit crabs only kill snails when they need shells, and there are only 3 crabs, and I raised land hermit crabs for years so I've got plenty of the good kind of shells for them.
I have a few hungry hermits that would argue against that. LOL. Hermits are opportunists, they will kill a snail for food if they are hungry enough.
 

flower

Well-Known Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by acrylic51 http:///t/394244/new-90-gallon-tank-my-first-time-with-saltwater/20#post_3509109
Flower that's how I read your post in regards to snails......I do see it recommended here though about ungodly amounts of snails and stuff for tanks......
Yep...when I reread my post (after finding it) I certainly am glad you spoke up so it could be corrected. I believe in a good variety of critters for a CUC, the happy balance to make sure all algae stays in check is a hard call, and then we also need the "meat" feeders who clean up the left over food or a dead fish hidden deep in the rocks.
I have given up on hermits and gave them all away, mean little good cleaners they are. Now because of the seahorses I just have a good variety of snails...about 65 in the 56g...There is a serpent star that must have hitchhiked but the horses don't seem bothered by it. I also spotted one hermit that must have been hidden among the purchase of snails since this was a new tank and never had hermits, they were in the 90g reef not the 56g. I have some really itty bitty snails in that count about the size of a pinky fingernail tip. I have no idea how many is in the 90g anymore...no dead snails and no algae, so it must be happy enough. Best algae eater IMO are the urchins, but I can't keep enough algae to keep those alive. All that really matters is I have no trace of hair algae, that's a battle I hope to never have to fight again...LOL
 
S

siptang

Guest
Welcome to the site. Looks like you are in great hands!!
I totally like the fact that you have been researching. You also got a steal on a whole set up.
I hope you enjoy your stay here and feel free to ask for advises, tips or even to vent your frustrations.
Oh and keep the pics coming lol.
 

chaosfyre

Member
@Flower: That's fine, honey. :) Thanks for apologizing. Sorry I got frustrated at you, you are just trying to help, I know. BTW, there are pictures of the tank posted under my name, in albums. However, they are not current!
Ah, the difference may be that I try to keep my hermit crabs well-fed. Have you tried freshwater algae pellets? My little dudes are all over those things. The fish love them, too, once they get soft enough or once the crabs break the pellets up for them. The emerald crab enjoys it as well... Every night, all the pellets disappear. I wonder who is eating them? I caught the emerald crab at it at night, but he is so tiny right now, surely he couldn't eat it all....
Then again, the other day, my lawnmower blenny's belly was so big I was afraid to feed him, that he might pop! I think he might have cleaned up the rest of the pellet... Really, I need a camera on the tank at night.
@Everyone:
Good news everyone! I asked my boss today how much the lab charges for their osmosis water, and surprise! She said just bring a container and fill it up, no charge! They even offered to lend me one of their 20 L jugs, or their 4 liter glass jug. Not sure about the glass jug-- some of them have had acetonitrile or methyl alchohol in them, but we have recycled a few to put osmosis water in it, which we use for very sensitive experiments...And there are no contaminants showing up, which is impressive since the experiments are amino acid analysis. I guess its possible to get the glass clean if you rinse it really well. So, as long as I work there, I'll have access to free osmosis water!
Seems like everything is fated to help me along with this. Its almost too good to be true! :)
@Siptang: Yes, I do love research. I can't tell how many hours I spend just sitting here reading up about any little question that pops into my head. Research IS my major of choice, after all! And I'm specializing in animals, as well, with a minor in animal science. I've made the final cut for getting into grad school to get my PhD. One more symposium, and if I pass, I'm in! Just 10 people out of everyone who apply make it in. It is down to 25 people now. I'm crossing my fingers...
 
S

siptang

Guest
Looks like stars are aligned for you to start this hobby lol. Will keep my fingers crossed for you as well.
 
Top