No Luck with New Fish!

serbanc

New Member
I've had my tank set up for almost two years. It is aprox 100 gal refugium tank. All in all everything is smooth, and all my older fish (a blood tomato clown, a pajama razz) are doing fine. But any new fish I add die! I added 5 yellow tangs (at once) and three died (over a period of two weeks). About a week later I also added 2 liar tails and 2 blue tangs, and they also died... The shrimps, and the corals seem to do fine, and the water tests perfect everytime. Did I stress them by introducing too many at once? I am absolutely afraid to spend any more money on fish. Any thoughts?
 

ricks280

Member
SerbanC- It is obvious that u cannot add so many fish at the one time. However more informatoin is required with your parameters, you will also need to consider that even if the fish do well at the begining, your tank will not be able to host that many fish, espescially the tangs. You would have thrown your bioload into overdrive. Send us a little bit mroe information on your system setup and im sure that everybody will chip in and help you with the best advise.
RICK
 

renogaw

Active Member
you're adding too many fish at once. you aren't saying how you are acclimating them, but come on, 5 yellow tangs at once?? then even more fish a week later? you need to slow down, relearn the hobby, and do some research again.
 

nictavius

Member
Are u saying your tank is 100 gallons counting the refugium.....or 100 gallons and then you also have a refugium...because if it is 100 with the refugium then it is not large enough for most of these fish....
 

ophiura

Active Member
I agree that the tank is much too small to add this many fish at once.
Some of the biggest tank issues I've seen are in established tanks that folks decide need some sort of sprucing up.
What do you test for? How old are the test kits? What is you alkalinity?
But overall - long term - this would not have really worked anyway.
 

serbanc

New Member
Thank you everyone. It is a tough hobby to get a full grasp on, and such mistakes only serve as (expensive) reminders. Based on the size of the tank (about 100gal on top plus the refugium) I was told I would be more than fine hosting that many fish. I acclimate the fish using the drip method, and I test for PH, Nitrate, Nitrite, alkalinity, slinity and calcium. I test myself and I also have my local store check once a week. I suppose my biggest mistake was introducing that many fish all at once. In your experience, what do you find to be a good period between introducing new fish? Is it better done after a water change or in between - or does it even matter?
Finally, a bit more detail on the system: The tank on top has dual compact lights and a metal halide. The water goes into the overflow and passes through a felt like cloth, then goes into the refugium where I have Fiji mud and a type of caulerpa (with a light that's on 24/7). Live rock of course for the reef, and a couple of powerheads for movement. Finally, the protein skimmer use to run 24/7 also, but someone suggested that I may be overskimming and killing corals like a toad stool I lost, so I placed it on the same timer with the halide. I welcome any suggestions.
 
Top