If there was no "slick" on the surface due to the surface being aggitated then other filtration, be it a power filter, wet/dry, skimmer, whatever, would have the chance to remove the organics before a "slick" had a chance to form. Its the same thing a surface skimmer would be doing with the "slick".
IMO there are 2 methods that will work equally effective as Cap'n Pete has mentioned.
Choose a method that best fits your needs and good luck. I had this problem in the past and increasing the surface aggitation cleared it up in less then a day. Results may vary.