Open Brain Puzzle for the Experts

scopus tang

Active Member
A friend bought me an very nice tri-colored open brain as a thank you for fixing a log bed he purchased. This thing was totally awesome! I left it in his tank for 2 weeks after he got it, to make sure it had stabalized after the initial shipping. It was open and glowing after two weeks ~ puffing up to about twice its original size. Brought it home, drip acclimated it very slowly for an hour, before placing it in my tank. All tank parameters (mine vs. his) were dead on with the exception of salinity (his is several points lower than mine 1.023 vs. 1.026). Two days later, it was dead
. Tissue sloughing.
Only thing several of us here could come up with was chemical warfare, but the only other corals in my tank are mushrooms, purple gongorian, zoas, palys, two plating montiporas, Xenia, and a colt coral. I added several frags at the same time; a clove polyp, gonipora (yah I know, but I couldn't resist ~ the thing has doubled in size since he got it in), a mushroom leather coral, and three zoa colonies (all very small, and all from the same tank), and all survived with no issues. Can't find anything in any of the texts that indicates any type of chemical war should have occurred between these corals.
Anyone have any thoughts on what I might have done wrong? or why it died? I really want a very nice open brain in this tank, but now I'm afraid to try another one, cause I don't want to kill it. Any thoughts or suggestions are welcome, cause I really want to find an answer here. Thanks in advance for your input.
 

nycbob

Active Member
sorry to hear ur lost. hard to give u an exact answer. maybe it was too much stress bc of the change in sg?
 

artie1209

Member
Was the coral completely deflated when you moved it from tank to tank? If not the tissue could have torn during move.
 

mx#28

Active Member
Originally Posted by artie1209
http:///forum/post/2549088
Was the coral completely deflated when you moved it from tank to tank? If not the tissue could have torn during move.
I agree. The tissue sloughing after a move makes me think damage and a possible infection were the culprits.
 

angler man

Member
Can't goniopora be fatal to other corals? I thought I read it was one of the most noxious corals you can put in your tank. if that is true, could this be a case of Allelopathy?
 

scopus tang

Active Member
Originally Posted by artie1209
http:///forum/post/2549088
Was the coral completely deflated when you moved it from tank to tank? If not the tissue could have torn during move.

Originally Posted by MX#28

http:///forum/post/2549114
I agree. The tissue sloughing after a move makes me think damage and a possible infection were the culprits.
Have to say I didn't check on this, but so far as I know it was. I do know it was completely defalted when I placed it into the tank. Interesting ~ I'll have to research this some more. Thanx
 

scopus tang

Active Member
Originally Posted by Angler man
http:///forum/post/2549374
Can't goniopora be fatal to other corals? I thought I read it was one of the most noxious corals you can put in your tank. if that is true, could this be a case of Allelopathy?
Not according to any of the reading I've done ~ wouldn't say no, maybe someone else can point us further in this direction. Any idea where you might have read that at? Also, the gonipora was in the same tank as the open brain prior to my moving it to my tank without an issues, which would lead me to say its probably not the culprit. Thanks
 
Top