please read and reply thank you HELP!!!!

I got 3 clown shrimps today=) One male and 2 females...with a cholcate chip for their dinner. After I put it in my 10 gallon seahorse tank(there is no seahorse in there yet) After a while a female started to fight with a male...and then the female defeated the male and chase the other female. Is this suppose to happen?? Will they die?? What is the fighting mean?? is clown shrimp hard to keep?? can they keep it with seahorses??Thank you for reading please reply becuase im very worry about my 3 little friends here...dont want to wake up tmorrow and find out that they all died.... well...please reply... thank you bye~~~
 

dad

Active Member
I'm not sure about the fighting. Here is though some info I founf that might be of interset to you:Family: Hymenoceridae ("wax membrane") Harlequin/Clown/Painted/Dancing shrimps (Hymenocera picta - "painted or
variegated") feeding habits are absolutely fascinating. Their diet consists solely of the tube feet of echinoderms, the most popular
class being the asteroids (sea stars). They'll even eat Crown-of-thorns starfish. When they find a victim, a sea star for example,
they will turn it on its back and drag it back to their lair, where they'll systematically feed from the tip of one leg down to the
base and then start on the next one. This way, the animal is kept alive for some time. These shrimp are a very secretive species
and few of its habits have been observed under natural conditions. During daylight they keep to the protection of the reef and
only go out to feed at twilight or complete darkness. It's almost always found in pairs with the female being the larger of the
two. They grow to about 6cm (2.4") and live from low tide down to about 10 metres (33'). Their large foreclaws are not used
for feeding but rather display. I've never seen these offered for sale in Australia but have heard they are occasionally available
elsewhere. I wouldn't buy them unless you had access to a constant supply of sea stars. Apparently, sea stars can be kept
frozen and thawed out when necessary. Of course, you wouldn't be the smartest of people if you kept a pair of these in a tank
with a prized echinoderm. :)
 

rubberduck

Active Member
yes, but what i knew a guy who had two and he would have 3 CC stars in another tank and let the shrimp eat it until the star was almost deid and then swap it with another one and let the one heal. try that. but yeah they are in pairs
 

annanymous

Member
why would you even want to keep someting that eats your starfishes. and i think its very cruel to let the star be an inch from death, then let it regenerate just to put the poor animal through the whole tantrum again. :scared:
:eek: that is evil
 

speg

Active Member
Originally Posted by RUBBERDUCK
yes, but what i knew a guy who had two and he would have 3 CC stars in another tank and let the shrimp eat it until the star was almost deid and then swap it with another one and let the one heal. try that. but yeah they are in pairs
Thats a cool idea.
 

connor

Active Member
Originally Posted by annanymous
why would you even want to keep someting that eats your starfishes. and i think its very cruel to let the star be an inch from death, then let it regenerate just to put the poor animal through the whole tantrum again. :scared:
:eek: that is evil

sorry but thats life it happens in the wild to
 
Y

yeffre kix

Guest
Originally Posted by connor
sorry but thats life it happens in the wild to
:mad:
There are a lot of things that happen in the wild that don't need to be recreated in your tank. I think it is cruel to repeatedly subject a creature to being eaten and allow it to heal so it can be eaten again.
Why don't you try one of those acrylic tanks with the bubbles and plastic fish ?
 

bang guy

Moderator
Originally Posted by Yeffre Kix
I think it is cruel to repeatedly subject a creature to being eaten and allow it to heal so it can be eaten again.
I'm not saying your wrong, you might be right, but why do you think it's cruel?
 

ophiura

Active Member
This is always a tough call for me. I have, uh, a little "bias" shall we call it toward seastars :D Yup, this is what happens in the wild. A very interesting type of "parasitism" if you will. I'm not a huge fan of the idea all in all, but then I'm not one to question it.
I'm not opposed to people keeping them, so long as they do the research and have a responsible plan in place. Not an impulse purchase. I am happy when people do not buy Linckia stars for this purpose. They are over harvested as it is, IMO. I have often stated that, IMO, the most "ecologically" friendly way to keep these shrimp, is to take a chocolate chip star (easy to feed and thus to keep healthy) and cut off an arm to feed, allowing the star to regrow the arm in a sump or something. This is basically making the most use of a renewable resource. Seastars have an amazing ability to regenerate as the are commonly attacked by fish and things in the wild. So this is pretty common for them to deal with. It may not be the thing for everyone, and I do hope people don't take pleasure in the suffering of the star - that would be different.
 

ophiura

Active Member
LOL! Man that similar thread thing is dangerous :D! We're, uh, just updating with the new incredible info that has come out in the years since it started :D
 

bang guy

Moderator
I agree that Sea Stars that are getting scarce should not be used at all for the purpose of feeding. Since Sea Stars have no brain I don't see how they could possibly "suffer".
 
Top