PLZ HELP ME O_o

rykna

Active Member
Tankmates
What's safe? What's not?
by Will Wooten
Let's be honest, there are very few seahorse keepers who truly wish to keep their seahorses in a species-specific aquarium. Although there are some keepers who insist that no species of fish, coral, or invertebrate should ever be kept with seahorses under any circumstances, there are quite a lot of animals that will do exceptionally well with seahorses while still allowing the seahorses themselves to thrive. To guide seahorse keepers in stocking their seahorse tanks with non-seahorse inhabitants, I have compiled a list of species that are appropriate for keeping with seahorses. This list should be used as a guide only and not a definitive reference.
The species are categorized as either a 0, 1, 2, or 3. The 0's are the most docile species around-- they're even safe with seahorse fry! The 1's are completely safe all the time with small to large horses, almost no exceptions. The 2's are, aside from the occasional rowdy specimen, safe. The 3's are a bit of a gamble, but work in some cases; watch them with care and be prepared to relocate them if they become a threat to your seahorses. Species marked with an asterisk (*) are suitable tankmates for seahorses (based on their numbers-- 0, 1, 2, or 3), but often fail to thrive in captivity for various reasons. These species are not generally recommended for any tank, but they should be referenced anyway. Anything not on the list may not be safe for seahorses ever, but they may just have been overlooked (or in some cases may be a newly-described species). If you have any questions about unlisted species, feel free to e-mail the author or to visit our Tankmates discussion forum. By the way, the list so far only includes species safe for regular-sized, tropical horses. And please, please, please do not hesitate to ask about any one of the listed or unlisted species you may have a question about! Now on to the list...
 

larrynews

Active Member
copper will kill anything on the rock, anything in it that is good pods and such, and i would never treat in a main tank, my rule of thumb is, if you have any doubts dont put in the tank...i have a 90 reef with 300 lbs of rock in it and thousands of dollars of coral and one thing i have found the hard way, it is alot harder getting something out than putting it in....so owith my horwse tank if i have any doubt fish, meds, food it doesnt go in it.
hth
 

reef_dart21

Member
thx alot

now i nko i bugged u alot but one last question
i am ready to get a seahorse i have cleared all the fish and put them into a diff tank that were nasty cc starfish cowfish etc
so now which is the hardiest seahorse availble? for a begginer seahorse person like me
 

rykna

Active Member
Originally Posted by Reef_Dart21
thx alot

now i nko i bugged u alot but one last question
i am ready to get a seahorse i have cleared all the fish and put them into a diff tank that were nasty cc starfish cowfish etc
so now which is the hardiest seahorse availble? for a begginer seahorse person like me
No question is to small, from now on I plan to be available 24/7 here on the Seahorse forum. So ask away

Here's the top 2 seahorses recomened for beginers:



 

reef_dart21

Member
ok then since im not bothering u

i was thinking of a Captive Bred Reidi Seahorse - Hippocampus reidi
{EDIT}
i have found some techniques regarding this horse but i just wanted second opinion
 

rykna

Active Member
I have read that Reidi are harder to keep than Kuda and Erectus...I personally have not kept that species.
So far, the only thing I am convinced of, regarding in successful seahorse keeping, is dwarf seahorses. From my personal experiences I think that they are by far the most hardiest and easiest species to keep and care for.
 

monalisa

Active Member
Originally Posted by Rykna
I have read that Reidi are harder to keep than Kuda and Erectus...I personally have not kept that species.
So far, the only thing I am convinced of, regarding in successful seahorse keeping, is dwarf seahorses. From my personal experiences I think that they are by far the most hardiest and easiest species to keep and care for.
Ummm...IF you have the time and inclination to be sure they are properly fed and taken care of...not to mention the extra added bonus of hatching their food every day so they have something to eat. Then there's the question of water quality in the smaller tanks that these little guys require. Dwarf horses are definitely NOT for the faint of heart...
Lisa
 

reef_dart21

Member
i have to hold up on the horses for now for some reason my nitrate raised and im trying to lower it by water changes but it just wont work
 

ophiura

Active Member
Reef Dart21 - I am REALLY confused by the several threads you have going on problems with your current tank, new inhabitants, asking about triggers, and now seahorses...??? The tank you have with the nitrate problems has a lot of fish in it, that would not be really suitable tankmates for seahorses. I really don't want to see you fail with this hobby, so it is important to go SLOW and keep things in perspective! It is unlikely the urchin is dying of old age.
I would also ask, again, that articles not be cut and pasted from other sites...this has been requested several times in the past.
 

reef_dart21

Member
Originally Posted by ophiura
Reef Dart21 - I am REALLY confused by the several threads you have going on problems with your current tank, new inhabitants, asking about triggers, and now seahorses...??? The tank you have with the nitrate problems has a lot of fish in it, that would not be really suitable tankmates for seahorses. I really don't want to see you fail with this hobby, so it is important to go SLOW and keep things in perspective! It is unlikely the urchin is dying of old age.
I would also ask, again, that articles not be cut and pasted from other sites...this has been requested several times in the past.

ur right i have been really jumping around with what to get i forget to say no seahorses due to i like variety and i have been wanting bigger fish so im just asking alot so then in the end i got an overview of whats best o_O
 
Top