Mine is not loud & I've had no problems with it. This hobby is just like everything else in life, you can ask for advice and then make the best decision for you. And I am in no way saying you should listen to me or anyone else on here. A lot of the things we know were learned from trial and error. I'm a firm believer that not everyone will have the same outcome or experience. We all work towards a common goal but all have different ways of getting there. If you can't afford a 150 - 200 dollar skimmer, then get what you can afford. And with that being said, this is an expensive hobby and some things you just can't skimp on.