question about acclimation!

ren9999

Member
I follow the instructions on this site to acclimate my order. but after 2 hours of acclimation how can it be possible that the water in the bucket is the same as in the tank???
Last I checked after 2 hours, there was a 10 degree difference between the bucket and main tank temperature.
what am I missing?
 

hot883

Active Member
Originally Posted by ren9999
I follow the instructions on this site to acclimate my order. but after 2 hours of acclimation how can it be possible that the water in the bucket is the same as in the tank???
Last I checked after 2 hours, there was a 10 degree difference between the bucket and main tank temperature.
what am I missing?
Are you adding tank water a little at a time to the bucket or dripping?
 

ren9999

Member
I am dripping. but at the end of 2 hours, there is quite a bit of water in the bucket and the slow drip is not going to be able to keep the water temp of the entire bucket same as in tank.
I think this problem costed me a fire goby last night when I put him in the tank. in a few hours he was dead and devoured down to the bone by my red leg crabs.
 

littlebuck

Active Member
i do mine a little diffrent. i keep them in the bags and then cut a small hole on the top of the bag and let it float on the top of my tank for an hour. Then afer there i add some water from my tank with a turkey baster and then do that for about an hour. I have never lost any fish or corals. its pretty much the same as you are doing but u wont have to worry about the temp.
 

mikeyjer

Active Member
Originally Posted by ren9999
anyone care to share how they keep the temperature in check in the bucket?
Are you running any fans or have vents blowing directly over the bucket? I never had a problem doing the acclimating procedure from this site. By putting a top over the bucket will help to keep heat in. :happyfish
 

stanlalee

Active Member
first off where are you getting your livestock with freezing/burning up water? 10 degrees from lets say 78 is either an icy 68 or a burning 88. and any typical mean figure you use as your temp a 10deg difference seems more than what should be expected. shippers use heat/cold packs to keep temps stable and local shouldn't be much different than any typical saltwater tank.
iyou can avoid that (worrying about temp acclimation) by floating the bag before drip acclimating or sticking your tank heater in the bucket used to acclimate. that way 15 minutes and you have the same water temp and you can put the heater back in the tank and carry on with the drip (with the drip water keeping your bucket water temp fairly stable there after).
I do one of two things.
a) test the bag water for pH and salinity. if its close to mine I just float the bag or do a fast drip to equalize the temp and dump the fish in (not the bag water). there are probably more things livestock could aclimate to but dagnabit I have never lost any livestock yet (on a side note even when I've just dumped livestock into the tank with no acclimation like the last mushrooms I bought and the bag was leaking something terrible by the time I got in the house. dumped them in and they've been fine)
b)float the bag to equalize temp then do the drip. But I dont do any 2,3 and 4 hour drips. In fact it aint even a drip what I do. I just put the livestock in a bucket with the water it came with and every so often pour in a little tank water both amount and time between adding based on nothing more than my instinctual intuition (obviously I dont dump a large quantity of tank water in at once or quickly but faster than a typical air line drip). when I feel its been enough I dump the livestock in the tank. Until I lose something (and I have hermit, fire shrimp, green emerald crab, turbo snails, false percula clown, damsel, lawnmower blenny, mushrooms, yellow and a few strands of button polyps, christmas tree coral and pom pom xenia) I have no plans to change anything. TOPS my acclimation time is 1hr. I aint recommending it just telling you what I do. a temp spike over 82deg will supposely kill xenia coral so other than watching out for that acclimation has been way overrated for me at least with the type of livestock I keep.
 

mrdc

Active Member
I do this. I float the bag for awhile to adjust the temp in the bag. I then do the drip method. I check the salinity of the LFS water and my water. Once the water is the same (which has taken about two hours for one fish and 30 minutes for another), I add the fish. So far so good.
My neighbor who has had a tank for 14 years uses this methos and has only lost one fish. I hope that it works as well for me.
 

ren9999

Member
I think I didnt explain my self well.
My question is the following:
I start acclimating by floating the bag for half an hour.
Then I pour the bag water into the bucket. I drip for say 1 hour. But by the end of this hour, there is no way the water temp in the bucket is the same as the tank. Last I measured, it is an 10 degree difference. Bucket water is 10 degree colder. If you think about it, it makes sense too. Because majority of the water in the bucket has been sitting around without a heater for 1 hour. Although there are some tank temp water dripped into the bucket, but that isnt enough to keep the entiure bucket water constant.
Are you guys telling me, you can drip for 1 hour and expect the bucket water temp at the end of the hour to be the same as the main tank??
 

hot883

Active Member
Originally Posted by ren9999
I think I didnt explain my self well.
My question is the following:
I start acclimating by floating the bag for half an hour.
Then I pour the bag water into the bucket. I drip for say 1 hour. But by the end of this hour, there is no way the water temp in the bucket is the same as the tank. Last I measured, it is an 10 degree difference. Bucket water is 10 degree colder. If you think about it, it makes sense too. Because majority of the water in the bucket has been sitting around without a heater for 1 hour. Although there are some tank temp water dripped into the bucket, but that isnt enough to keep the entiure bucket water constant.
Are you guys telling me, you can drip for 1 hour and expect the bucket water temp at the end of the hour to be the same as the main tank??
I think your problem is pouring the water into the bucket. NOT NECESSARY. Place the acclimated bag into the bucket keeping the water in the bag. Drip your tank water into the opened bag. If your bucket is hot or cold it will make your water temp. fluctuate. HTH
Then again, I always float my bag in the tank, open the bag and add my tank water to the opened bag. I don't place my bag or water in a bucket. Not lost a fish yet.
 

ren9999

Member
but if you do that, the bag could only hold so much water. even if you completely fill up the bag, your fish might still not have acclimated properly since say salinity might not have matched the salinity in your tank yet.
right?
 

mikeyjer

Active Member
Originally Posted by ren9999
oh, heheh that sounds good.
can i use this method for all fish / coral acclimation?
Yes you can. I've never lost a fish doing the Acclimation with the drip method into a bucket though..... :happyfish
 

azocean709

Member
my temp is way off too when i drip...my simple solution...I bought a small heater <for like a ten gallon tank> and another thermometer. I got a one gallon "critter Carrier" it is used for nothing but acclimating new animals. I do a Fast Drip. maybe 4 drops a sec. almost a steady stream but not quite. but it seems to work really well as i can keep both temps the same and Know that they are the same. and usually, but the time the one gallon carrier is full...<about 2 hours> they are ready to go into the tank...never lost one yet.
 
Top