Reef safe fishes to add

thang45

Member
I have 9 fishes total in my 90g tank.
Can someone please recommend new fishes for my 90Gal tank? Hopefully it would be compatible with my current stock. I wanted add 2 more orange clownfish, but I read on this forum it is a BIG No No to mix with different clown in the same tank.
Current stock:
One Blue tang - 3" long
One Yellow Tang - 4" long
Two Banggai Cardinal (Adult size)
Two Firefish Purple
One Green Mandarin
One Orange Spotted Goby - 4" long
Two Black Clownfish (Adult Size)
Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you
 

lietz06

Member
For a splash of color the purple psuedchromis is a good choice. I've always like hawkfish...they're very personable. You could get some type of blenny..lawnmower, bi color, midas blenny. Or maybe some sort of dwarf angel maybe a flame or coral beauty. There's a few suggestions. Let us know what you decide:)
 

thang45

Member
Originally Posted by lietz06
http:///forum/post/3149755
For a splash of color the purple psuedchromis is a good choice. I've always like hawkfish...they're very personable. You could get some type of blenny..lawnmower, bi color, midas blenny. Or maybe some sort of dwarf angel maybe a flame or coral beauty. There's a few suggestions. Let us know what you decide:)
thanks for the advice.
I google all the names you have given me, and I like the following:
dwarf angel
flame fish (I think)
coral beauty
are those reef safe and are they compatiable with my current stock?
I added a copperband fish and my yellow tang chased it all day long. so I returned it to my lfs.
Anyone have True Percula Clownfish and Black and White Ocellaris Clownfish ion the same tank?
 

thang45

Member
Is it a good idea to buy the following tangs:
Powder Blue Tang
Sailfin Tang
Sailfin Tang, Desjardini
Lieutenant Tang
Two Spot Bristletooth Tang
Naso Tang
I'm more concern it may not be compatible with my Blue and yellow tang.
 

lietz06

Member
I think you were talking about the flame hawkfish...I have a spotted hawkfish( I like the flame more bc they're so much more colorful) and he's cool. He follows around when I'm looking at the tank...he's perched on a rock watching what I'm doing. I wouldn't get 2 angels....they don't get along-so I'd choose which one you like best. On this site I don't even think they'll sell you two unless you say they're for 2 different tanks. As for the tangs....I honestly wouldn't get anymore. You said you have two in a 90....that's probably tanged out-sorry. I would say that the hawkfish and the angel should get along with your fish. Every fish has it's own personality...but since the more peaceful fish( firefish, goby) where in there first there shouldnt be any problems.
 

flower

Well-Known Member
Originally Posted by thang45
http:///forum/post/3149751
I have 9 fishes total in my 90g tank.
Can someone please recommend new fishes for my 90Gal tank? Hopefully it would be compatible with my current stock. I wanted add 2 more orange clownfish, but I read on this forum it is a BIG No No to mix with different clown in the same tank.
Current stock:
One Blue tang - 3" long
One Yellow Tang - 4" long
Two Banggai Cardinal (Adult size)
Two Firefish Purple
One Green Mandarin
One Orange Spotted Goby - 4" long
Two Black Clownfish (Adult Size)
Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you

There are so many fish in the sea.....here is the best purchase you can make when choosing your critters. This book tells you what gets along with what...how big they are when adults, the minimum tank size they need and what they eat.

 

btldreef

Moderator
Originally Posted by thang45
http:///forum/post/3149751
I have 9 fishes total in my 90g tank.
Can someone please recommend new fishes for my 90Gal tank? Hopefully it would be compatible with my current stock. I wanted add 2 more orange clownfish, but I read on this forum it is a BIG No No to mix with different clown in the same tank.
Current stock:
One Blue tang - 3" long
One Yellow Tang - 4" long
Two Banggai Cardinal (Adult size)
Two Firefish Purple
One Green Mandarin
One Orange Spotted Goby - 4" long
Two Black Clownfish (Adult Size)
Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you
Well Flower beat me to it with suggesting Anthias.
I don't suggest psuedochromis, especially if you have shrimp in your tank (which you really should it it's a reef set up with that many fish, IMO). Psuedos are normally a bit aggressive too, just another thought to keep in mind. I also don't think it's a good idea to mix clowns, some people have luck, but since you have two that are already adults, I wouldn't risk it when there are so many other options out there.
I have a coral beauty angelfish and love her. Here's the catch, she attacks everyone I've added to the tank since her. She's killed two blennies on me and a small hippo tang. She always pounces right on new additions, normally chases them around and then leaves them be, BUT, she has killed a couple as well. She's never nipped at any of my corals, but it's always a risk with angel fish, even the Flame Angel can be a risk. There are a couple dwarf angel fish that are a little safer to go with, if you search this site you'll find someone who says what they are, which I don't follow because I already have one dwarf.
Hawkfish is another one that can be aggressive and you have a fairly peaceful tank.
You're yellow tang may chase any new additions as well, they're known to do this. If you do decide to go with a powder blue, make sure it's going to be the last tang you add. Naso's are normally very peaceful as well as sailfins. I don't know if you should go with another tang though considering you already have two in a 90G, but if you must, I'd go with a Naso or Sailfin, they're much more peaceful. You could also try a Kole Tang.
I'd stick with smaller fish, like reef chromis, basslets, anthias, clown gobies or a royal gramma. Try a blenny, they have so much personality and some, such as the Lawnmower Blenny are beneficial to the tank, helping it stay clean of algae.
Good luck.
 

thang45

Member
Originally Posted by lietz06
http:///forum/post/3149774
I think you were talking about the flame hawkfish...I have a spotted hawkfish( I like the flame more bc they're so much more colorful) and he's cool. He follows around when I'm looking at the tank...he's perched on a rock watching what I'm doing. I wouldn't get 2 angels....they don't get along-so I'd choose which one you like best. On this site I don't even think they'll sell you two unless you say they're for 2 different tanks. As for the tangs....I honestly wouldn't get anymore. You said you have two in a 90....that's probably tanged out-sorry. I would say that the hawkfish and the angel should get along with your fish. Every fish has it's own personality...but since the more peaceful fish( firefish, goby) where in there first there shouldnt be any problems.
Nope I was talking about the Flame Angelfish, but I like flame hawkfish you have mentioned.
I think you are right, I'm all tanged out.

BTW, what type of Angel is peaceful?
Originally Posted by Flower
http:///forum/post/3149782

There are so many fish in the sea.....here is the best purchase you can make when choosing your critters. This book tells you what gets along with what...how big they are when adults, the minimum tank size they need and what they eat.
I forgot that I have that book.
I really like your recommendation. I cannot recall if I have ever seen this before, very nice.
Originally Posted by BTLDreef

http:///forum/post/3149821
I'd stick with smaller fish, like reef chromis, basslets, anthias, clown gobies or a royal gramma. Try a blenny, they have so much personality and some, such as the Lawnmower Blenny are beneficial to the tank, helping it stay clean of algae.
Good luck.
FYI, I had to google all the names you have provided because I cannot picture it.
The information you have provided is excellent, thanks for sharing.
I love the Bartlett's Anthias, and Clown Goby Yellow. I already have a orange goby, can I still get the Lawnmower Blenny?
 

thang45

Member
If I want to buy the fishes below, can I buy two of each or is that too much?
Bartlett's Anthias
Clown Goby Yellow
Lawnmower Blenny
 

btldreef

Moderator
Originally Posted by thang45
http:///forum/post/3150291
If I want to buy the fishes below, can I buy two of each or is that too much?
Bartlett's Anthias
Clown Goby Yellow
Lawnmower Blenny
The Antias and Clown Goby will be fine in pairs, or more, but I don't suggest having more than one blenny in the tank.
 

thang45

Member
thanks for the advice, I will be looking to buy 5 fishes this week.
I will leave the tang out for now, but may want one in the near future. I hope that is ok.
 

btldreef

Moderator
Originally Posted by thang45
http:///forum/post/3150701
thanks for the advice, I will be looking to buy 5 fishes this week.
I will leave the tang out for now, but may want one in the near future. I hope that is ok.
Adding five fish at once is a lot on the bio load. If you're going to add them all of one type in hopes of them schooling, that's fine, but I wouldn't mix different types at once. Add one species, wait at least a week, then add the other.
 

thang45

Member
Originally Posted by BTLDreef
http:///forum/post/3150932
Adding five fish at once is a lot on the bio load. If you're going to add them all of one type in hopes of them schooling, that's fine, but I wouldn't mix different types at once. Add one species, wait at least a week, then add the other.
if there is a choice, does it matter which type I added first?
 

btldreef

Moderator
Originally Posted by thang45
http:///forum/post/3151290
if there is a choice, does it matter which type I added first?

With what you're looking at getting, not really. You could do it in any order. They're all fairly peaceful fish.
 

thang45

Member
Originally Posted by BTLDreef
http:///forum/post/3151326
With what you're looking at getting, not really. You could do it in any order. They're all fairly peaceful fish.
Thanks!
Originally Posted by Fretfreak13

http:///forum/post/3151343
A midas blenny was suggusted earlier, and you seriously can't understand their beauty unless you see one. Pictures don't do them justice, IMO. Check out this short vid on yotube.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oFFmFeZx60g
Holy cow. I want one. You are not kidding.
They are very nice.
Well I'm on my way to buy one, if they have any. :)
thanks for the video.
 

thang45

Member
Well I went to the store and cannot find what I was looking for. Anyways, I picked 3 purple Anthias. thet are very nice.
I have asked them to order midas blenny and Bartlett's Anthias for me. Hopefully they will have it soon.
 

btldreef

Moderator
I just bought my Anthias 5 minutes ago. I'll keep you up to date with what mine do....
I did notice that when the guy at the LFS was moving things around, they seemed to try and hide, so maybe if they're stressed they're shy? I thought they were a schooling fish that stayed out in the open. We'll see
 
Top