salinity

keith gray

Member
OK I know Im gonna get a lot of different answers but I'm gonna ask anyway.
What does everyone think ideal salinity is for a tank with corals and fish.
I have heard from 1.023 all the way to 1.027.
thoughts anyone
 

cranberry

Active Member
Originally Posted by Keith Gray
http:///forum/post/3173054
I have heard from 1.023 all the way to 1.027.
There is no ideal. They all work.
I've seriously kept tanks at every salinity. All my tanks are different right now as I tested the other day for another thread. I've kept mixed reef, SPS only, FOWLR, macro tanks, Snail tanks..... they honestly do well as long as it's within the range.
 

flower

Well-Known Member
Originally Posted by Keith Gray
http:///forum/post/3173054
OK I know Im gonna get a lot of different answers but I'm gonna ask anyway.
What does everyone think ideal salinity is for a tank with corals and fish.
I have heard from 1.023 all the way to 1.027.
thoughts anyone

Your right different opinions. Here is mine:
My book says 1.026 is the SG of the natural ocean. That is where I want my SG.
If you have an auto top off system (ATO) setting your SG at 1.026 would be fine. If you don't have an ATO...I think you should keep your SG below that.
The reason being is that water evaporates, the salt remains...when your water line drops down, the SG goes up. If you already have your SG at the highest point then your SG will be too high between evaporation and top offs.
Point is, no matter what, without an ATO that is going to happen. So you hear people having an SG reading between 1.026 and like 1.024 for example.
Now for the real most important thing...STABILITY. Ocean critters have for many thousands of years lived in an environment where nothing changes. They have not learned to adapt.
So a new marine critter may get acclimated to your tank...what it can't handle is a constant change. Bouncing around the SG, PH, and Alk will wreak havoc on a critter that has lived for generations in a constant unchanging environment.
Your tank is their world, if you want your "pet" to live, you have to duplicate its natural world. So what you want to do is create a constant reading. You want to have your SG, PH and Alk at the same reading at every test, as perfect as you possibly can.
If set your SG at 1.022 then always strive to keep it at 1.022, if you MUST raise it or lower it...do so very, very slow.
 

keith gray

Member
I just ordered a refractometer yesterday. I think I can see where it is now once it arrives and then I can try to keep it around 1.022. I do not have autotopoff and do this manually. My water does not seem to evaporate very much, maybe a gallon or two a week. I don't know why or if that is good or bad, but I don't have to top off a lot.
thansk for everyone's opinion on this
 

reefkprz

Active Member
Originally Posted by Cranberry
http:///forum/post/3173059
There is no ideal. They all work.
I've seriously kept tanks at every salinity. All my tanks are different right now as I tested the other day for another thread. I've kept mixed reef, SPS only, FOWLR, macro tanks, Snail tanks..... they honestly do well as long as it's within the range.
I am inclined to agree. you generally need to set it up for your own goals for the tank.
in my reef I run higher because its easier to maintain high trace element levels with a higher SG due to the amount in the salt mixes. this is ideal for me. 1.027
in my fowlr I run lower just to save on salt
 

srfisher17

Active Member
For many years, I (and many others) kept fish-only tanks as low as 1.017. The idea was less stress on the fish and fewer parasites. I now keep my reef at about 1.027; my FOWLER tanks at about 1.022.
 
Top