Sand in reef tank.

greenwolf52

Member
I'm going to be snagging some sand from the local beach down here in daytona for my new octo setup and was wondering about. if i later on down the road want to convert htis tank to a reef setup, will this sand still work and be ok? it's kind of fine and not like the chunkier stuff we are use to seeing in reefs.
 

coachklm

Active Member
you would have to go far far off shore to find ---safe sand as beach sand is nasty (99.9% of the time)
 

oceana

Active Member
Originally Posted by greenwolf52
bump
MOST of the time that sand is brought in by the truck load and NOT natural beach sand do the vinigar test and you will quickly see that this is the case. also they are so filled with junk you really dont want it even if it is the right stuff. your talking about a small tank so finding some real cheap from a local reefer or just buying some dead sand will not cost much at all.
Ie:25 buck will buy you a 50 pound bag around here
 

greenwolf52

Member
Originally Posted by dskrezyna
Great advice everyone, wish people would appreciate them! Apparently it's not what they want to hear. ***)
What the heck makes you think it's not what I want to hear? Am I not allowed to get multiple opinions without people calling me unappreciative?
I appreciate everything everyone has told me so far and will continue to do so. However, I do not appreciate this quote.
Thank you
 

oceana

Active Member
Originally Posted by greenwolf52
What the heck makes you think it's not what I want to hear? Am I not allowed to get multiple opinions without people calling me unappreciative?
I appreciate everything everyone has told me so far and will continue to do so. However, I do not appreciate this quote.
Thank you

i would not take to much offense. a noob poster making a poorly placed and uncalled for remark should not be a reflection on what you can expect from this forum. its a great place
 

greenwolf52

Member
thank you, oceana.
I trust this sight very much. i am also a rookie on these forums, and would've normally ignored that. i expect great things from this forum but don't always listen to 3 or 4 people's advice and go running to the bank with it. i want to hear as many opinions as possible and from those opinions i develop my own personal opinion. i can see you already understand this and maybe now someone else will.
 

saltn00b

Active Member
wolf, do a keyword search for beach sand and you will find a number of threads about this exact subject. a lot of people tried and had problems or have been dissuaded to do it from other's experiences.
 

sts

Member
I have an excellent web page for ceph care but not sure if it is ok to post on swf. Anybody know?
 

oceana

Active Member
Originally Posted by STS
I have an excellent web page for ceph care but not sure if it is ok to post on swf. Anybody know?
if it has ads, is selling somthing or even links on that site to sites that have these features it is a big no no.
other then that you should be safe
 

maelv

Active Member
Wolf let me let you in on a secret....shhhhhhhhhhhhhh....don't tell anyone....But I did what you are inquiring about...I was just starting out and I went to the beach on Pensacola when I was visiting my in laws and guess what.....scooped me about 65 lbs of sand put it in a clean cooler with some of the beach water and hauled it off back to Kansas City. Ran with that in my 42 gallon....thinking I had a fairly successful tank....Boy was I wrong. The problems didn't show up immediately, but about 6 months into it for absolutely no reason at all, my levels went out the roof, in a matter of 4 days, I had lost EVERYTHING in my tank...including some damsels (and these seeds of satan survive everything...they are like cockroaches ha ha ha ha)...don't know if if the sand was the reason, but it really was a pain in the a********** couldn't keep it clean, new crap that I thought I had cleaned out of it kept surfacing....think I found a bottle with a note in there **send help, please*** once...LOL..
Then come to find out, I had read on this site in several places, it is illegal to take sand from the beach in Florida...now I am going to be on America's most wanted for taking some sand...So I did what any rational person would do....disposed of the sand to get rid of any evidence...
No your honor, that was not me on the day in question on the Pensacola Beach!

But in my opinion, I would not take sand from the beach and place it in your tank....like someone put it in one of the forums on this site....(not verbatum, but in generalization) Look at your skimmer...all the bubbles that rise to the top and the nasty skimmate that is left over in the collection cup......well the beach is the oceans collection cup with all of the oceans waste and bi-products....
 
Top