skimmer for a 10g tank

nozwal

New Member
I have heard mixed messages from a lot of different people, some say u could maintian a reef tank of a 10g tank and some say its too hard for corals in a 10g tank, but i would like to try anyways with a coral or 2. should i invest in a protien skimmer for a 10g tank? but im new to this protien skimmer thing, what does it actually do and would it help a lot if i plan to have a coral or 2 in a 10g tank?
 

yannifish

Active Member
Welcome to the site!
I can't answer your question about whether you need a skimmer for a ten gallon tank, but I can tell you what a skimmer does.
In a protein skimmer, large amount of microbubbles are injected into a column of water, rise to the surfaces, and pop into a collection cup. With the bubbles comes dissolved organic wastes, which accumulate in the collection cup. How the process is called foam fractionating, and is actually a simple process. The dissolved organic material in the water are attracted to the bubbles and held there by the surface tension of the water. So, they "ride" the bubbles to the surface, and are popped into the collection cup. This is a very simplified explanation, and there is much more information available online.
There are a couple ways that bubbles are injected into the water, most commonly air is mixed with water in a pump and pumped into the skimmer body. More bubble = more efficient. Also, the taller the skimmer the longer the bubbles are exposed to waste, which means more efficient.
Skimmers help improve your water quality by removing waste matter before it has a chance to develop into nitrates. Skimmers are very efficient once they are functioning properly.
Hope this gives you some idea of how a skimmer works!
 

novahobbies

Well-Known Member
This is an interesting topic, and there are a couple points of view about it. Some people maintain that a skimmer should be on ANY reef tank, even if it's only used some of the time. Just as on large tanks, the thought process here is that the skimmer will remove much of the excess DOC's in the tank, keeping the water as pristine as possible (and as a side effect, increasing the O2 saturation as well).
Other people swear that a skimmer isn't necessary on a small tank, and that the weekly partial water changes that MUST be kept up anyway in small systems will be more than adequate to keep DOC's down.
I think what you should look at more closely right now is your lighting, flow, and heating parameters of the small tank. What lighting do you have that you plan to use to keep the corals alive? Your coral choice will depend on the quality of light you have pumped into this tank. Likewise, increased light may equal increased heat, so you need to make sure your temperatures can remain stable...this isn't always the easiest thing to do in a small environment. You may need to consider a fan blowing across the tank top, or possibly even a small thermoelectric chiller such as an ice probe.
Finally, what do you have in place for flow? A couple koralia-1's or the similarly-rated koralia evolutions would probably be your best bet.
Personally, I feel that religious water changes of around 3 gallons a week will benefit the tank more than a skimmer, but if you choose to there are a couple good nano skimmers available. If I were you, I'd focus on the lighting and cooling issues first, then move on to the skimmer.
 

yannifish

Active Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by novahobbies http:///forum/thread/385655/skimmer-for-a-10g-tank#post_3383062
Personally, I feel that religious water changes of around 3 gallons a week will benefit the tank more than a skimmer, but if you choose to there are a couple good nano skimmers available. If I were you, I'd focus on the lighting and cooling issues first, then move on to the skimmer.
+1 on the water changes.
Another thing is a 10 gallon tank is already very limited on space, you may not want to devote the tank space to the pump that drives the skimmer.
 

novahobbies

Well-Known Member
An internal combined skimmer like the Aquatic Life skimmer would be ideal if the OP went this route. The pump is integral to the skimmer body. I've owned this skimmer, and can attest to its effectiveness. It was a little fiddly at first and produced a moderate amount of microbubbles for the first couple weeks, but it wound up being a good skimmer after break-in. (Still no match for my new Tunze "nano," though!)
 

nozwal

New Member
hey guys, as for flow i got a Tunze nanostream 6015, which is more than enough for a 10g tank. and for lighting i for the stock fluorescent light t hat came with the tank and i added 2 strips of actinic LED white and blue combo lights of 12k each. not sure if this is enough for simple coral but the store owner said that is enough light for some corals. (shrug)
I kno that bigger the tank the easier to keep corals in but im limited to resources so i can only have a 10g tank but i would like to do anything possible that i could with my tank to maintain a coral or 2.
 

nozwal

New Member
on a side note, i just read my LED lights package and the specs are 12,000k white & 453nm blue combo 3 watts. and i got 2 strips of these. on the package it says these lights promote strong coral growth.... i just dont kno how much strips i would need in a 10g tank lol
 

novahobbies

Well-Known Member
Okay. What brand LED strips did you get?
Since you're just starting out, I would recommend something very simple and forgiving to keep -- some red and blue mushrooms, perhaps. These guys can survive under very low lighting, even as low as a simple standard fluorescent strip. They are also pretty flexible regarding water quality, but of course you will want to keep your tank parameters as pristine as possible.
 

1guydude

Well-Known Member
honestly if u have the $ id go with nano tunze. This is wat i plan on getting for my 10 gal. Also remoraC has a nano i believe! Are these the leds u can integrate and connect together? If so i suppose if u had enough of em, they would be ok. Id start with something easy like a mushy rock or something!
 

nozwal

New Member
tnx for the help guys, i picked up a biocube skimmer that is good for up to around 30 gallon. but i think im gonna wait for a bigger tank so i can put corals in.
I might be getting a 24 gallon with a stand for $100 tmr. used of coruse but still good deal :D
i'll just hold off on adding stuff and buying things for my 10g now. gotta save up for 24g !
 

monsinour

Active Member
not to step on toes or hijack the thread, but i will be making my zoa garden in a 10G using my frag stand. I was going to get a skimmer and possibly use the fluval c2 HOB (i think thats the right model) or the small fluval canister taht my wife found. Its not the 105 i dont believe. For skimmers, I see there are a few to choose from. Recomendations? I am in the boat of any SW tank needs a skimmer. Lights over my 10G will be a DIY LED setup of 12, maybe 24 3w Cree LEDs. As cheap as LEDs are (for small setups) I really cant imagine going with anything else.
 
Top