To float or drip..that is the question!

sparkee61

Member
Today, I visited another aquarium store and I asked the owner how he acclimated his corals and fish. He said that the true proffessionals float in the bag for 30 minutes then place fish/coral directly in the tank.In my research, most proffessionals drip. How about it people? What do you do?
 
Y

yote

Guest
I drip every thing,,fish,coral,invert. Even rock that I get at my LFS if it has cool hitchhikers on it that I can see.
 

sigmachris

Active Member
This is a good question for the LFS. If they get a shipment of 200 animals are they really dripping everything???
 

monalisa

Active Member
Drip acclimate. I always look up the recommendations on this site for whatever I get.
Lisa :happyfish
 

1journeyman

Active Member
Originally Posted by sparkee61
Today, I visited another aquarium store and I asked the owner how he acclimated his corals and fish. He said that the true proffessionals float in the bag for 30 minutes then place fish/coral directly in the tank.In my research, most proffessionals drip. How about it people? What do you do?
Was he implying that "floating" a bag better acclimated a creature? That's absurd.
Many stores don't drip because they don't want to spend the time. Not because floating is somehow better.
 

taz_12777

Member
Floating works great to get your new purchase to temp but to get it acclimeted nothing beats the drip method to slowly get it to were it needs to be.
 
B

blackburnd

Guest
I didn't vote... I do both... I float for about 20-30minutes. Then drip for suggested acclimation time..
 

mandarin w

Member
Why would you waste your time floating. Especially if the fish was shipped. That fish is in a toxic waste dump by the time you get it. And the oxygen in the water is probably very low. You should get the fish out as soon as possible. and new water getting to it.
Think about it. Ok you are floating the fish so the water gets to be the same temp as the tank. That is the only possible thing that could be done with floating. But then you take the fish away and put it in a bucket on the floor and start dripping water into the bucket. I doubt you have a heater in the bucket. because there isn't going to be enough water in the bucket to start off with. So as that bucket sits on the floor for what 45 minutes, or two hours, the water will start to cool some, and then you will put it in the tank. So that is 4 temp changes. cool in the bag, then warmed up and the cool in the bucket, and then warm in the tank. In my opinion that is way too many temp changes in a short period of time, and will be very stressful on the fish.
As mention earlier, fish stores don't drip because their are too many fish that come in at once to try to drip. You realize how hard and how long it would take to drip 80 - 100 fish. Plus they don't care if just floating the fish is hard on them, and the fish get sick and dies a week later. They are counting on that fish being in your tank by that time.
 

acrylic51

Active Member
I agree "floating" doesn't due crap......just gives the fish already in the tank a chance to size up their prey........ :scared: No Kidding.......I drip everything except snails.........I've dripped over an 8 hour period before......My Achilles and Powder Blue got the treatment.....
I do have to disagree with the statement about LFS don't drip.......I've been associated with quite a few in my area, and everything was dripped upon arrival no matter how late we had to stay........
 

mandarin w

Member
I have to say, that I know two stores that do drip. Those are the better stores. The tanks and everything in the store is very well cared for. But I have to also say I know of 3 others (used to be 4) in the area that just float. There the fish usually look crappy. Most look like they have ick. or other ailments. The fish also don't seem as alert and healthy as the stores that drip.
The forth had to close it doors last fall. Went broke I guess.
 

sign guy

Active Member
I tink the questistian is a little vauge if you meen float and release then that is absurd but to float with blacked out bags for 30 min then slowly add water for another hour ....well thats not as god as dripping but if I knew the a lfs was foating and relesing that would be the last time they saw me
 

triga22

Active Member
I would float all fish accept angels,wrasses, and the hard to take care of fish. I would drip all corals.
 
Top