top down picture contest JUDGE THREAD

fedukeford

Active Member
My vote is for fishieness too, murphs pic is AWSOME too, i just like how fishieness pic has a few diff corals, and a clown, its just more diverse
 

mr. guitar

Member
I vote for Murphs!!!! The Clam is very colorful and the picture is "detailed". Fishieness's picture, to me, had to much stuff in it.
 

tx reef

Active Member
Well, I guess fishieness is the winner. One other judge and I have voted so the third judgeis not needed since fishieness recieved both votes.
Agreed?
 

murph145

Active Member
not like this matters or i care but this is the most messed up contest ive ever seen lol
how is this voting system working that u guys came up with i mean yeah its ur contest but just a lil wacky if u ask me....
i agree fishiness's photo is awesome i could care less if i won or not but in all seriousness if u guys are planning on posting a contest id make sure its ran right next time....
like being clear and to the point not a billion rules....
and if someone over post dont DQ them let them take back the extra photos u guys are just way off...
and hows the voting work?? why did any SWF.com users vote if only the judges vote counts??
anyways like i said i dont care to win a prize or a frag but this lil contest is way wacky
 

tx reef

Active Member
I don't know either. I am just trying get this contest finished. I just voted because NateP206 said for the judges to vote for the two choices. It was his (her?) contest so I am not going to say anything.
I am going to start another contest. Something simple and easy and once again I will provide the prize (unless someone else wants to).
 

murph145

Active Member
lol i mean i think that its awesome that your doin this tx reef and i would gladly offer a prize on the next one too to make it more interesting....
i could offer some of my Jolly Green Giant palythoas that i got names on zoaid.com no one else has gotten a frag from me b4 so it would be a nice frag of some ncie neon green big polyps in my original top down pictures
what u thinhk??
im all for contest just this one kinda went array
 

joncat24

Active Member
i still think your clam pic was awesome murph....if I saw one like that I would buy it in a heartbeat.....nice pics
 

fishieness

Active Member
huh. i thought the contest was easy to follow as long as you followed the directions?
oh well. if there is another one id probably enter that one too.
just another excuse to take more pictures :joy:
 

fishieness

Active Member
email returned!
i dont even know if i will be able to claim the frag however. i am still i nhigh school and dont get home until about 6 o clock every day (well, noon on fridays, but would that be availible). anyways, i dont NEED a frag either (although they are always fun)
makeing these contests and donateing frags is really nice of all of you guys
if i knew how to ship id do it myself
 
Top