Was this worth the 7 bucks??

big

Active Member
Seeing this the other day I just could not resist for 7 bucks. With all the testing already. I thought maybe one less to do all the time would be great... I still guess every once in a while a regular Ammonia test should be done...... But this looks as it, with a quick glance may be worth while???????????
Was it a waste of 7 bucks or not?....Thanks all for an opinion. Warren
 

teen

Active Member
ive never checked my ammonia, i dont even own an ammonia test kit. but i guess its worth it if you test for ammonia regualrly.
 

anonome

Active Member
I actually have one in my qt and it works very well. I tested the water for a while to make sure it was working. They say to change it about once a year. I have only had mine about 7 months and have started to test again just to be sure. It is still working. I agree not a pretty picture on the main tank, but you shouldn't really have a problem on the main tank if you don't over feed and do routine water changes. I only test my main tank maybe once every 3 months or so for ammonia. You can usually tell if something is amiss by watching the tank....which I know we all do on a daily basis.
 

cdangel0

Member
Got one, works - looks like shat but that's why we put them in a corner where we don't have to look at 'em.
 

big

Active Member
Originally Posted by WHO DEY
can u get one for phos, nitrates, etc... :thinking:
I wish, I hate to test

Location wise, mine was there just to take the picture
 

hatessushi

Active Member
Originally Posted by WHO DEY
can u get one for phos, nitrates, etc... :thinking:
I've not seen any for phos, trates, etc.. but I have for Ph and temp
 

michaeltx

Moderator
just use it as a guide and not as a deffinate. nothing replaces a good set of test kits.
The only bad thing about this product is that people use it as a fool proof way to see what the ammonia is and it can be inaccurate and doesnt give a precise measurement of what the ammonia is. so when the ammonia starts to rise it will take a measureable reading before it even goes to the alert stage on the dial.
mike
 

hatessushi

Active Member
Originally Posted by MichaelTX
just use it as a guide and not as a deffinate. nothing replaces a good set of test kits.
The only bad thing about this product is that people use it as a fool proof way to see what the ammonia is and it can be inaccurate and doesnt give a precise measurement of what the ammonia is. so when the ammonia starts to rise it will take a measureable reading before it even goes to the alert stage on the dial.
mike
Funny thing is that the test kit I have has a small container with a smaller version of the sensor that you see in this device. You get a sample of the tank water and you just put one of these sensors in it and match up the color which is the same as this Seachem device. They is one difference with the test kit is that you can test for Free Ammonia adding drops and putting a sensor in the sample. So, I don't see any difference from using this device other then it is always in the water.
 

ophiura

Active Member
Originally Posted by HatesSushi
Funny thing is that the test kit I have has a small container with a smaller version of the sensor that you see in this device. You get a sample of the tank water and you just put one of these sensors in it and match up the color which is the same as this Seachem device. They is one difference with the test kit is that you can test for Free Ammonia adding drops and putting a sensor in the sample. So, I don't see any difference from using this device other then it is always in the water.

It may still be an inaccurate test kit. It is similar in respect to dip strip tests - but these are no where near as accurate as other ammonia test kits. I would never recommend them. So this, eh, good general concept, but I wouldn't trust my tank to it.
 

darknes

Active Member
I'd like to know how precise this thing really is. Any traceable amount of ammonia is detrimental to a saltwater tank. If this thing doesn't even start to read until the ammonia is up to something like 0.1, you could have lost half your livestock by then. If it starts to change colors (or whatever it does) when any trace of ammonia is present, then it wouldn't be so bad.
 

booduh

Member
I agree, by the time that sensor picks up any trace of ammonia, you already have a big problem and dead or dying livestock. Especially if you have inverts and corals.
 

rykna

Active Member
I had one in my 90 gallon for several months.....never registered anything....nothing nada.....

Glad other people had better luck,
 

chipmaker

Active Member
Don't underestimate them, Yes they do work and its easy to find out if they work or not. They are a visual indicator and I have stated time and time again they are super for starting a tank in the cycle as it will go through allthe color changes as ammonia agoes up and levels off and then comes back down and yu never have to drag out a test kit until its back to rthe safe level, to verify. I have added a fraction of a drop of ammonia to a tank it it took less than 5 minutes for the indicator to pick up the ammonia and indicate a change. They work. Just wave it over a open bottle of ammonia it will change color rather quickly. Do a test yourself with freshwater and some ammonia.....HOw fast it picks it up is dependant on the position its in the tank at, and how gfood of circulation you have. I position my indicatos near a filter pickup strainer or such. Oh and they also make smaller versins like Barry Baracudam and Rose Red etc which are all cartoon caracitures, and they are somewhat smaller. If the size of the indicator itslef bothers yu , just trimn it down in size but do not cut into the centwer of it where the indicator pad is.Its nly thin plastic and is easy tocut. The cartoon character ones are cheaper by about 2 bucks and much easier to cut down and make smaller without looking indcator color references. I just slide mine down between sandbed and glass in area of pump pickup etc and they work just fine.
 

chipmaker

Active Member
Originally Posted by Rykna
I had one in my 90 gallon for several months.....never registered anything....nothing nada.....

Glad other people had better luck,
Evidently you did not ever get a rise in ammonia then or it would have indicated it.
Did yu have live rock? sand" Odds are its hard to get an ammonia spike in a tank with sufficient live rock and sand and not overstocked or fed. Flame me if ya all want, but I just do not do ammonia tests anymore nor do I do any nitrate or nitrite tests. ONce my tanks are mature and stabile I rarely do any checks once I get to know them. I am not alone in this either. There is just no way a tank with sufficient levels of live rock and all fish present and accounted for and not over loaded is going to get any ammonia buildup, and without ammonia there is not going to be any nitrite either.
 

xdave

Active Member
I think something like this would be good to catch spikes. You never know when something will die in a hidden spot. Once a tank is cycled, I only test nitrate except after after any new livestock addition.
 
Top