What is the inch per gallon ratio

orangespot

Member
I heard several answers...Just want to hear what you guys think...especially for a 54 gallon corner....do inverts count?
This is what I have...percula clown, coral beauty, two green chromis, yellowtail damsel, golden head goby...Am I maxed out...all fish are just over an inch except coral beauty which is three inches
 

orangespot

Member
What about the current bioload that I have? am I maxed out? have sixline in quarantine so hoping it is okay...if not...I will fish out my two chromis...
 

lefty

Active Member
You could add the sixline, but I wouldn't add any other fish after that. How's your damsel? They're usually aggressive little guys. If I were to consider taking a fish out, it'd be that one. :)
-lefty
 

benj2112

Member
Using the 1inch for every 5 gallon rule...
P. Clown=3 inches
Coral Beauty=4 inches
2 Green Chromis=6 inches
yellow tail damsel=3 inches
golden head goby=7 inches
total = 23 inches of adult fish
23x5=115 gallon tank needed for this amount of fish
P. Clown, Coral Beauty, yellow tail damsel, golden head goby, sixline wrasse (3 inches) = 20 inches of adult fish
20x5=100 gallon tank needed for this amount of fish
I would say you are over the max.
 

bdhough

Active Member
That rule is just a loose rule. Your mix of fish is definitely good and even that allows for more fish. The fish you have picked are on the smaller size allowing you to add more fish but I would keep in mind it takes quite a while for your fish to reach adult size. My green chromis are barely 3 inches and i've had them for over 2 and a half years. Another factor is the amount of rock you have. Do you have alot? If so that allows for even more fish. A reef can yeild a higher percentage fish per gallon than a fish only with no live rock. SOoooooooo. I'd say your sixline will be ok but add no more fish to that tank. You may run in to aggression problems as well. I added a sixline at one point and my yellowtail damsel went after him pretty hard.
 

orangespot

Member
I have 50 pounds of liverock and some simple corals too...I will add the sixline and that will be the end of it...I will maybe attempt to get the damsel out. Thanks for the comments...all the fish are tiny...golden headed goby is really small as are the other fish.
Thanks again..
 

benj2112

Member
Hey bdhough...that is interesting with the reef equals more fish. I have never heard that before. What is the basis for that? I understand the rule is loose as some smaller fish need big swimming room or put out a lot of waste for their size (or little), but I have never heard that a reef=more fish (yeah in nature, but I would think that is a food issue.) Are you going on the assumption that more live rock/sand means more bacteria to break down waste in our closed systems? Maybe I just answered my own question, but I would love to hear what the thinking behind that idea is.
Not a rip at all just curious?
 

pohtr

Member
Or is it that the live rock takes the place of water and reduces the total gallons available for the fish or is it that there are now more hiding places which makes the fish think they have more room? Or a combo of both which might cancel each other out????
 

bdhough

Active Member
Its a combination of all of that. There are more hiding places, more "natural" food to be had, and the all important more bacteria. More bacteria means being able to sustain a higher bioload. This is also contingent on your clean up crew. If you have just fish and nothing to eat their waste then yes you need to keep less fish and do more water changes. But get some starfish, hermits, shrimp, and snails to eat the excess algae and waste and you can keep that extra fish. You must also very carefully mix and match. Different shapes, different species, different colors. Sample good tank would be a sixline, 3 green chromis, 2 percs, goby, and hawkfish/blenny. All look, swim, and just plain behave differently allowing them to coexist without much incident. You could pretty easily do that in a 55 if you wanted to if you also had 75lbs of rock, etc etc.... Bigger tank and you could easily do a tang+dwarf angel......So on and so forth.
Also how often do you want to do water changes. I once heard of a guy who had crazy crazy amounts of fish in a 180 (6 tangs, 3 heniochus, 6 anthias, and more....) but he did water changes all the frikin time. Thats extreme but you get the idea.
 
Top