Which one can stay?

[kilmca]

Well I added a Hippo Tang and a new coral, I think its a Goniopora. Everything is doing great. Here are some pictures.
I have two tangs now, a sailfin tang and the hippo, and i know if i keep them too long the tank would get over crowded. The sailfin tang is about 5" and the hippo is 3". My dad is setting up a 180 gallon tank soon and i'm going to give him one of the two tangs. Which one should it be, I have a 120 gallon tank?

 

[f1shman]

I say give up the sailfin. The blue compliments your tank better

 

[jayc]

I like the hippo better so I'd say the salfin. But there both beatiful fish. Let us know what you decide.

 

[ricks280]

get your dads tank!!!!!!!!!!! and keep them both! (rick)

 

[andretti]

I agree with Rick. Though both get rather large, the hippo gets longer and the sailfin gets taller. Personally, I'd keep the hippo

 

[salisbury a d]

I've always liked the sailfin out of all the tangs. But I can't get one of my own

my tank is only 46 gallons.
Adam
looks like I'm out numbered so far

 

[racinereef]

i would keep both i have up to 3 tangs in my tank at one time and wish i still had them sailfin hippo and yellow all in the same tank and its only 125 so they will live together just put the yellow in last :happyfish