Originally Posted by
funkyman
http:///forum/post/2583468
The peppermints may have not been the answer for you, but they didn't have anything to do with the increase in population of the aptasia.
You also have to be careful and make sure you're getting actual "peppermint" shrimp, and not camel back shrimp. Some places don't know the difference between the two.
If you want to save yourself some money, Joe's Juice is nothing more than kalk paste. If you make your own, you can also make it a lot thicker than what Joe's Juice is which will get it to stay where you want it better.
Some people have had success by getting the aptasia to retract back into it's hole, and then sealing it in with super glue or two part epoxy (the same stuff used for mounting frags) to seal it in to it's doom.
I have to disagree, I believe peppermint shrimp were almost certainly the cause for the increase in my population. I started with a huge population of aiptasia several thousand and got them under control with Joes juice. After I had the population under control for a couple of months all I had were some aiptasia that were under rocks in holes or other places that I couldn't reach during this time I saw very little evidence of propigation then I decided to get some Peppermints. The shrimp were eating the aiptasia and I witnessed on several occasions but I started to notice that the aitpasia had started propigating again and very quickly I was noticing another 10 or so a week so I started treating with Joes juice again. For whatever reason peppermints don't seem to survive in my tank not sure if my Sally lightfoot preys on them or what they just slowly disapear over a few weeks now I haven't seen a peppermint for a month or so and my aiptasia has almost stopped spreading again. My theory is that the shrimp are leaving pieces of the aiptasia or spreading them when the shread the aiptasia apart and those pieces are growing into new aiptasia.