It depends on the Carbonate and Calcium consumption rate in your tank. A tank with few corals can easily get by with only limewater. A fully stocked reef with lots of clams and corals will probably need an additional supplement.
Originally Posted by guppie
My tank is made up with almost all soft corals, so will give it a try and just keep checking my levels. thanks
Give it a try. Keep in mind that many softies consume massive amounts of Calcium, especially Leathers.