tony detroit
Active Member
For the newbies I'm going to write a little discussion for you explaining different equipment somewhat in-depth. If anybody sees any mistakes I have made, or has any suggestions feel free to comment and correct them. Just don't sidetrack this thread, it is to inform beginners and help eliminate some of the multiple questions we see daily and be used as a future reference.
Skimming:
A protein skimmer is a device where you mix water with loads of tiny tiny air bubbles. The smaller and more air bubbles, the better. The waste in the water sticks to the bubbles and raises out of the skimmer to a collection area so it can be disposed of. There are many types of filtration, but none truly REMOVE the waste like a skimmer does. There are a few different ways skimmers do this-
Venturi Nozzle- The velocity of the water passing through an inlet creates a vacuum, sucking air in with the water. These are the standard in skimming, but not the best.
Beckett Nozzle-Like a venturi, but you use a much more powerful pump and pull in a lot more air. They function better, but need to be tuned constantly and use lots of electricity.
Mazzei Nozzle-Also like a venturi, but a bit more efficient
Needle Wheel-In my opinion the best out there right now. Manufacturers such as ASM, Euroreef, Deltec, H and S and others are using this method. The difference between a needle wheel and the other types is the air on other types is sucked in after the water goes through the pump, on a needle wheel the air sucks in before the pump, and then the pump mixes it vigourously via pinwheels in the pump with the water before shooting it to the skimmer. These skimmers are the best for saving on your electric bill and don't need to be adjusted like a beckett. I have yet to see a venturi or mazzei nozzle skimmer perform like a needle wheel can.
Downdraft Skimmers-These are usually beckett or venturi fed skimmers and push the water from the top down, giving you a vigourous air/water mixture. These are great skimmers, but I still do not believe them to be superior to a needle wheel.
Recirculating Skimmers- These use needle wheel inlets on dedicated recirculating pumps. These pumps are used only for the purpose of mixing the water in the skimmer more vigourously and adding air at the same time. A seperate pump is used to supply the skimmer with water. I feed mine with my water drains coming from the main tank. These are the best skimmers on the market IMO as of right now.
I really recommend keeping your skimmer clean. You will get much more foam production because the foam can rise easier on a cleaner skimmer tube than a dirty one. This is the main reason larger commercial skimmers have neck washdown features, this keeps the neck clean and lets the skimmer perform optimally.
On new tanks, it is a general rule of thumb to wait 2 months before incorporating a skimmer.
Some new skimmers require a break in period. After starting them up sometimes you may have up to a week in time before you really see them produce a skimmate foam. It is also not unusual for your skimmer to stop making foam for brief amounts of time after feeding, having your hands in the tank, doing waterchanges, etc. This is all normal.
When deciding on purchasing a skimmer take into account
-Your total water volume, sump, tank, everything.
-Do you plan on doing a system upgrade
-In sump models or external models are always better than hang on models
-Buy a skimmer rated for 2x your tank size to be safe if you can
-Electrical Efficiency
Skimming:
A protein skimmer is a device where you mix water with loads of tiny tiny air bubbles. The smaller and more air bubbles, the better. The waste in the water sticks to the bubbles and raises out of the skimmer to a collection area so it can be disposed of. There are many types of filtration, but none truly REMOVE the waste like a skimmer does. There are a few different ways skimmers do this-
Venturi Nozzle- The velocity of the water passing through an inlet creates a vacuum, sucking air in with the water. These are the standard in skimming, but not the best.
Beckett Nozzle-Like a venturi, but you use a much more powerful pump and pull in a lot more air. They function better, but need to be tuned constantly and use lots of electricity.
Mazzei Nozzle-Also like a venturi, but a bit more efficient
Needle Wheel-In my opinion the best out there right now. Manufacturers such as ASM, Euroreef, Deltec, H and S and others are using this method. The difference between a needle wheel and the other types is the air on other types is sucked in after the water goes through the pump, on a needle wheel the air sucks in before the pump, and then the pump mixes it vigourously via pinwheels in the pump with the water before shooting it to the skimmer. These skimmers are the best for saving on your electric bill and don't need to be adjusted like a beckett. I have yet to see a venturi or mazzei nozzle skimmer perform like a needle wheel can.
Downdraft Skimmers-These are usually beckett or venturi fed skimmers and push the water from the top down, giving you a vigourous air/water mixture. These are great skimmers, but I still do not believe them to be superior to a needle wheel.
Recirculating Skimmers- These use needle wheel inlets on dedicated recirculating pumps. These pumps are used only for the purpose of mixing the water in the skimmer more vigourously and adding air at the same time. A seperate pump is used to supply the skimmer with water. I feed mine with my water drains coming from the main tank. These are the best skimmers on the market IMO as of right now.
I really recommend keeping your skimmer clean. You will get much more foam production because the foam can rise easier on a cleaner skimmer tube than a dirty one. This is the main reason larger commercial skimmers have neck washdown features, this keeps the neck clean and lets the skimmer perform optimally.
On new tanks, it is a general rule of thumb to wait 2 months before incorporating a skimmer.
Some new skimmers require a break in period. After starting them up sometimes you may have up to a week in time before you really see them produce a skimmate foam. It is also not unusual for your skimmer to stop making foam for brief amounts of time after feeding, having your hands in the tank, doing waterchanges, etc. This is all normal.
When deciding on purchasing a skimmer take into account
-Your total water volume, sump, tank, everything.
-Do you plan on doing a system upgrade
-In sump models or external models are always better than hang on models
-Buy a skimmer rated for 2x your tank size to be safe if you can
-Electrical Efficiency