Can anyone ID these?

krishj39

Active Member
Ok, sorry to add more info on you again Steve, but I thought it would be helpful for everyone to know the corals in the first pic are a stony coral, not button polyps or something.
Second pictures looks like hydroids, which are the one of the phases of jellyfish....I don't remember seeing them in your tank before.
 

dburr

Active Member
2nd pic is red feather dusters. They stay small like they are and are harmless.
What does the first pic feel like? hard or soft to the touch?
Dan
 

007

Active Member
I am on the fence about the second picture. Either feather dusters or hydroids. A clearer picture and a detailed description of behavior will help to give an accurate ID.
 

spsfreak100

Active Member
The second picture are Hydriods. I've been unfortunate enough to have hundreds of these things in my tank. They also spread quickly.
My hydriods have come in contact with a few species of Acropora, Montipora and Heliopora, with no bad affects as of yet. But, that doesn't mean that eventually there will be bad affects.
I attached a picture of one of my "hydriod colonies." >>>This<<< picture shows the calcareous tubes of the hydriods, and the picture attached shows the oral disk along with the tentacles.
Graham
 

steve40

Member
The first picture does feel hard but it has a soft covering, it does appear to be spreading a little (which I think is awesome if it covered that whole rock).
 

bang guy

Moderator
First picture looks like Porites to me. I can't tell if the second is dusters or Hydroids. Like SPSfreak, I'm leaning toward Hydroids.
 

dburr

Active Member
I must be the only one to see the tubes. Gram's pic doesn't look anything like the second pic.
Take a clearer pic, then we'll know for sure.
 

jonthefb

Active Member
i agree that the first is a stony, looks very similar to a porites but hard to tell...second pic also looks liek either hydroids which are nasty or featherdusters, which are good!
good luck
jon
 

j21kickster

Active Member
the first pic- is it hard- if so it is common to see porites on live rock- especially the brown variety- althought they kind of look like zoanthids that have overgrown a once stony coral- but....
 

bdhough

Active Member
I don't know where you guys get porites for the first pic but i think we need a better picture, as well as some contrast for size.....
Im of the mind that its a very young favia colony but favia "mouths" are bigger and i've never seen a small colony before. There are alot of stony corals out there with the distinct borders that im seeing such as madracis or stephanocoenia. Heck i can even almost make out stalks and a head polyp leading me to think it might be an unexpanded alveopora, which i doubt it is but you never know.....
Another pic if you can STEVE40
 
Top