It is cool to hear from other Long Islanders where they go.
To answer drea's orignal question, I have not been successful at getting a flame angel to live more than a few days.
I don't understand why because other fish purchased from the same places are doing well and it is strange that 3 out of 3 flame fish have died in my tank.
As far as places to go I try to visit as many as possible, here is a list of some of the places I am aware of:
Petwarehouse - like everyone said, nice selection, nice staff and has good prices
Suffolk county reef & fish- Could use more fish but still decent selection, I find their fish are in good health, the guys that run it are really nice and very helpful and their prices are good
Tropical paradise - great selection- decent prices
Aquarium adventure - place looks huge but selection is not as big as it looks though they seem to carry some cool fish. Their prices are ok only if you join their club and get the discount
Country Critters - has a great selection of beautiful fish though their prices are on the higher side
Pet Stop - call me crazy but the few times I've been there they have very very few saltwater fish though that guy John who works there is awesome and really knows his stuff
Mega pet(I think thats the name of the store in Plainview) -Good selection, good prices, tough to park