Giant hairy mushrooms

chrisnif

Member
My LFS has some of these in their "off limits" "display only" reef but the one guy who works there said he could get me one being I've spent so D*** much money there. He has some that are literally the size of dinner plates and one is "turkey platter" size. Just wondering has anyone had these do they need special care or attention. I know i read somewhere that they are related to carpet anemones and can (and will) eat things that might get near it. I mean some of these do have a mouth the size of a silver dollar. So are they safe, did I read BS (wouldn't be the first time) but I do notice the only fish in the reef are green chromis, aka disposable fish.
 

katsafados

Active Member
I have green hairy shrooms.. There in my 10g tank and they grow pretty fast(only have 2x40watt pc lighting). I dont do nothiong special for them.. just le thtem grow with the light, once ina w hile try to feed them mysis but they hardly ever take it before everything else grabs the food. I already fraged them once and tyhe tank hasnt been up fot a year yet.
Mine are'nt the size of dinner plates since its only a 10g and I need to keep them under control.
I heard also when they are that big they eat fish or anything that perches ontop of them. Heres some pics of mine (probably 5 inch in diameter on good days)
Attachment 235933
Attachment 235934

 

btldreef

Moderator
I have kept them in a 40G and now they're in my 155G. I don't feed them directly, although I'm sure they feed on any filter feeder food that I add. I started with one a year ago and now have three (about to be 5 since two are splitting again). Mine are about 5-6" across when fully open. I've had them under PC's, T5HOs, ans now are under MHs and have noticed more rapid growth now that they are under the halides.
As for eating fish, it is possible, but it is rare that it happens unless they fish is injured or ill. My blenny and watchman gobies pearch on them constantly. They actually cover the goby burrow slightly when fully open.
To me they are some of the easiest corals to care for. Good luck!
 

flower

Well-Known Member

I never heard of mushrooms eating fish, I thought they were filter feeders and never fed them anything but coral food I add to the tank....I have some huge green stripe ones. They are almost the size of a coffee cup saucer and still growing. Should I be concerned?
 

btldreef

Moderator
Originally Posted by Flower
http:///forum/post/3190197

I never heard of mushrooms eating fish, I thought they were filter feeders and never fed them anything but coral food I add to the tank....I have some huge green stripe ones. They are almost the size of a coffee cup saucer and still growing. Should I be concerned?

I would not be worried, those don't eat fish and the ones that do have like a 1% chance of doing so
 

eyebedam

Member
Well I hate to rain on ones parade but I have quite a few of these that started out as just 1 in a jbj nano cube back in the day. I had 4 different shrimp gobies get eaten by my mushroom. I watched it happen to the last 2. It could be because the fish was just small enough but I assure they will eat something that small if given the oppourtunity.
Also Id like to add my shrroms are alot larger than the hairys posted on this thread they are every bit the size of dinner plates.
 

chrisnif

Member
Thanks much, this was my fear, I wont be getting these in that case :)
Originally Posted by eyebedam
http:///forum/post/3190230
Well I hate to rain on ones parade but I have quite a few of these that started out as just 1 in a jbj nano cube back in the day. I had 4 different shrimp gobies get eaten by my mushroom. I watched it happen to the last 2. It could be because the fish was just small enough but I assure they will eat something that small if given the oppourtunity.
Also Id like to add my shrroms are alot larger than the hairys posted on this thread they are every bit the size of dinner plates.
 

katsafados

Active Member
Originally Posted by eyebedam
http:///forum/post/3190230
Well I hate to rain on ones parade but I have quite a few of these that started out as just 1 in a jbj nano cube back in the day. I had 4 different shrimp gobies get eaten by my mushroom. I watched it happen to the last 2. It could be because the fish was just small enough but I assure they will eat something that small if given the oppourtunity.
Also Id like to add my shrroms are alot larger than the hairys posted on this thread they are every bit the size of dinner plates.
SEE TOLD YOU GUYS!
 

katsafados

Active Member
Originally Posted by Chrisnif
http:///forum/post/3190315
Thanks much, this was my fear, I wont be getting these in that case :)
You can gwt them just make sure they dont get that big.. I cut mine into 4 when they get to big and sell them.. then the little piece left on the rock regrows..
 

1boatnut

Member
I have one that has 3 heads. 1 is about 7-8"across when open. My gobies love to sit in it .Guess I have been lucky,but so far they have yet to eat any fish
 

bang guy

Moderator
Elephant Ear Mushrooms are notorious for eating fish. Larger hairy mushrooms will eat fish if the fish isn't wary enough.
 

ajroc31

Member
I had one in the past, it was a size of dinner plate. It split few times, had to give him away, it was taking too much space. Its a great coral. You can't kill it, unless you try to. Some of his offspring survived without direct light for months. He survived a tank crash, cow fish toxin release, bad maintance by me, and still survived dividing multiple times. Feed it shrimp from a grocery store, and it will be happy. It never ate anything, and imo, if the fish is caught by it, it probably deserved to die, since it closes pretty slowly. I have 5 left, but I am taking them to LFS; need more room for other corals, smallest one will stay.
 

spanko

Active Member
From Bob Fernner at wet web media.
"Coral anemones, mushroom anemones or false corals are perhaps the most celebratedly hardy "corals"; often reproducing readily in well-kept systems. They have much to their merit besides, being relatively inexpensive and available in reds, blues, greens, purples and variegated patterns. Corallimorpharians require little specialized care as you will see.
Classification: Taxonomy, Problems, Relation With Other Groups
Coral anemones are closely related to the stony or true corals, indeed they are sometimes grouped as part of the same Order (Scleractinia) as a sub-order. One arrangement:
Phylum Cnidaria: Phylum Cnidaria: Stinging-celled animals. Anemones, corals, sea fans, jellyfishes, sea pens... Polyps and/or medusae stages
Class Anthozoa: Class Anthozoa: Polyp stage only, stomach divided in numerous compartments.
Sub-Class Zoantharia (Hexacorallia): More than eight and multiples of six tentacles.
Order Corallimorpharia: Coral anemones. Solitary or colonial, flattened mushroom-like anemones. Short, stubby tentacles radially arranged. Look like true corals, but lack skeletons. About ten families. Most common genera Actinodiscus, Ricordea, Corynactis, Rhodactis, Amplexidiscus. (the last two can eat unwary fishes... commonly clowns)
Individual polyps 1 inch to 1 foot across."
 

spanko

Active Member
And from James Fatherree
Genus Amplexidiscus:
"Lastly we get to the genus Amplexidiscus, which has only one member. These are called elephant ear mushrooms due to their large size, and they’re all Amplexidiscus fenestrafer. How big is large? While they may stop growing at a little under a foot across, some may keep on going until they’re more like a foot and a half in diameter. That’s a big mushroom.
Elephant ear mushrooms are typically brown to greenish in color and they have a broad but short base. They also have lots of tentacles on their discs, but these are again unique. Their tentacles are often relatively long for a mushroom and are very simple and thin, often ending in a point. They really look a lot more like a big flattened out sea anemone than anything else. Easy to tell apart from the others.
As you might guess, these can also thrive under a broad range of lighting, from low to high intensity, and will also prefer lower currents. Thus, they can also be placed practically anywhere the current isn't too strong. However, these can apparently produce a sort of toxic mucous which can affect corals it comes into contact with, so I suggest you keep them from even coming really close to other things. Again, keep in mind how big they get, as well.
These can also reproduce asexually in aquariums, but unlike the others they don't tend to form big clusters. Instead of splitting or spreading around pieces of themselves over and over, these tend to live a solitary life, or form only smaller groups. Typically, there will be less than a half-dozen in any given spot.
Lastly, these are big eaters, indeed, that can also eat fishes. So beware, as these can and will get hold of fishes you don't want eaten on occasion. You'll need to give them some meaty foods to keep them happy, which can include small fishes if you like. Really, because these are so big and are able to eat smaller fishes, they aren't very popular with most hobbyists for good reason."
"
 
Top