Green Brittle Star reef w/fish?

sduda

Member
I recently purchased a green brittle star from this site (AWESOME). I wanted to add just like one or maybe two fish to my reef setup. Do you think this is a problem (translated as will the starfish eat my fish!?!). Any input would be helpful. I searched the site first and didn't come up with anything really definitive unless the green brittle star was really large. This is about 3" in diameter (at least at this point).
 
I think you fish should be safe. I have a brittle in my tank and it seems to leave all the fish alone.
Mine gets fed a piece of shrimp or clam once a week, just so he don't decide to snag a snoozing fish. It is actually kinds cool to do !! I have these green tentacles come out from under his rock and wrap around my hand till he finds the food. Lets go of me and drags lunch under the rock with him. Kinda like a 1950's horror movie monster :p
 

banshee

Member
It may become a problem when it gets bigger. I just had to remove mine from my tank as it had a taste for live fish. Mine was pretty big, though.
 

mlm

Active Member
If you keep it well fed it should not be a problem. I have had mine for over a year now and it has not eaten any of my fish as far as I know.
 

rook

Member
Is it just the green serpents that have a habit of eating fish or any serpent? What about brittles?
 

mlm

Active Member
I believe its the green brittle that some people report having problems with. The serpent stars (no spike things on legs) are supposed to be a better choice but in my opinion are not as aggressive when it comes to eating leftover food.
 

ophiura

Active Member
The green brittlestar is a known predator in the wild, however, not everyone has this experience in captivity. Some do, some don't. Even some who feed them, still have problems. Mine is not. In fact, I have a dead snail in that tank right now, and he (and a serpent) are sitting there next to it looking forlorn, wondering how to eat the yummy smelly thing.
Some people report the green eating anything...shrimp, crabs, snails, fish.
Mine is very large (and grew very fast, BTW), but appears to be pretty docile.
There is no biological distinction between brittlestars and serpentstars, and my serpentstars are rather aggressive feeders. Some of my brittlestars are rarely seen. Others report the same species of brittlestar hunting. I suspect it is an individual thing, and no one can guarantee how your brittle will behave. It may eat something, it may not. It is a great risk to small fish- damsels, clowns, gobies, etc.
Keep any brittlestar or serpentstar fed...do not allow them simply to scavenge. This may simply mean putting a piece of food near it, or into its arms, or something. They will eat just about anything, but we tend to load our tanks full of scavengers. Just good to make sure it gets something.
Yours will grow big, fast. But they are good in a sump or refugium should you have any problems with it down the road.
 

broncofish

Active Member
Hey Ophiura a little OT, but have you seen that anartic special on pbs, these divers put on 3pairs of long underwear, and 4 dive suits and go to the ocean floor below antartica. They found these gigantic red britttle stars, biggest I have ever seen. Now back to the topic. I have 2 brittles, and I feed them each silversides every other day, they also grab pieces of brine as it floats by. I have seen my 6 line wrasse and the green sharing a hole under one of the rocks, and was a little scared. Neither star has turned agressive yet, and I think if I keep them well fed I should be fine.
 

sduda

Member
Thank you all for the information. Sounds like I should be in relatively good shape. Broncofish (or others), what the heck are silversides? I have seen this all over posts but have no clue where to get them or how you feed them.
 

rook

Member
yeah, what do you guys use to give food to stars ect on the bottom of the tank.
I don't like to put my hands in there if I can avoid it. For one my maroon gets very protective of the tank and attacks me, and two I don't want to contaminate or stress the tank.
 

broncofish

Active Member
Ever seen any videos of the reef? they are those fish that swim in schools of thousands. Little fish(about 1-1 1/2 inches) I buy them frozen at the lfs, and cut a couple off of the block and run them under hot water. Silvesides gobble them up, great for anemones also
 

broncofish

Active Member
I have a feeding stick(a long bamboo barbacue kaob stick) don't tell my wife she's been looking fo it for about a year. I mostly just hand feed the though. I think they have gotten used to it to. They take a long time to come out when I just stick in there on the

[hr]
, but whe I stick my hand in they come cruising out right away, some of my fish will eat hand fed now actually. My yellow cubicus comes up and snacks on seaweed from my hand, and so will the six line my shrimp tries to clean my arm hair. My wife thinks I am going into scuba withdraw sometimes.
 

ophiura

Active Member
Yes, I have seen half of that special. I missed the first part to an inferior Simpson's episode. :( But it was very cool indeed, and not just literally!
 
M

mozart200

Guest
beware the evil brittle star.
mine started out, docile and shy.....as I type he is munching on the neighbors cat...
actually he ate a clown a couple days ago and about a month ago my lawnmower blenny
went awol....
I thought the were just chillin in a hole somewhere, but I did a major aquascape remodel today and they be gone.
I am going to sneak up on him tonnite and put him in my other tank.
 

rook

Member
Do you think that my regular old black brittle star would have the tendancy to eat my fish. I am missing a couple, a blue chromis and an algae blenny. I kind of wrote them off as either suicide cat food, or that they wander off in the back of the tank and died where I can not see them.
I do not feed my brittle!!! I guess that should start to happen?
 

rook

Member
Also, (sorry about kind of stealing someones thread)
I am missing an emeral crab?????
The brittle could not eat that, could it??
 

ophiura

Active Member
Brittlestars are sold to tanks as scavengers, and indeed, this is what they will do. If a fish dies, it will eat it, and unfortunately, many brittlestars get the blame for killing it. I do not assume that a brittlestar caught any animal unless I see direct evidence that it has done so...meaning, the fish struggling in its arms. There have certainly been reports of this, but I suspect at least as many false reports.
People have blamed brittlestars for killing and eating tangs, which is pretty funny. People tend to look at the brittle, and overlook other issues- age of the tank, delicate nature of the fish, other water parameters, etc. It is risky to do so.
It is unlikely, but possible, that it ate the crab. Anything is possible. It is possible that there is some hitch hiker crab in their responsible too. Anything is possible.
I have a huge green brittle who is trying to figure out how to eat a dead snail right now and has been for 2 days. My black brittle is rarely seen at all, though he also knows the snail is dead. They are all circled around it wondering what to do. Waiting for Mom to come and help them.
 

maxi

Member
My brittle star has been returned to the lfs. He was caught dragging a live snail under his rock and I was feeding him shrimp once a week. When I lifted his rock to remove him I found 6 empty shells! ByeBye brittle.
 

supertube

New Member
I have a huge brittle star and it doesn't seem to bother anything. He will eat anything dead but I have not loss any live fish to him.
 

dinfill

New Member
I just got a package w/2 brittle star and added them in the tank last night. I have not seen them since. Hiding somewhere. After reading this, I'm not sure what or how to feed them. New at saltwater, so suggestions and help are needed!
 
Top