I have a 56G Column tank and the same filtration unit you are using. I never cared about the filtration unit rating in terms of the GPH, but I am quite new to this hobby, so take my advice with a grain of salt.
I have two pumps, both Hydor. One rated at 600GPH and the other at 850GPH. They are running in a cycle, so only one on at a time, but I notice that it seems better in the tank with the 850GPH pump going. The fish tend to play in it more and overall, it seems like actual water is moving around. I am planning to add two small 240GPH pump to supplement these pumps and provide some undertow currents that go opposite the above pumps to make sure I am getting the proper circulation. I have felt that this might be best if I wanted to downsize and go for two 600 GPH pumps since no one single pump will be too strong.
From what I have read, the recommendation is about 10 times the amount of water volume is the rating you should get for a system with a single pump. If you are planning to go with more than 1 pump, then have them on a cycle, and I would recommend trying things out for yourself. From the reading I have done and the LFS, it seems that the fish really need the circulation to allow their bodies to be at their best and to allow the fish to grow. I would imagine doing what's best for the fish would help you get the coraline algae you want in your tank. I am also trying to get that in my tank but I am trying to be patient after running the lighting system I have caused a diatom outbreak that I have under control by turning off the lights completely for the time being.