Okay, finally some one with the same thing in their tank as mine, I have the same encrusting black spong, every so often it basically comes apart in these little balls that float around your tank for days, if they land in a shaded area that has decent waterflow but they can attach they will. I have been wondering for about 1.5 years if I was the only one with this type of sponge. I have never gotten a full ID but it is a sponge, mine does this about every 30 days or so. It will also be much smaller when it is done, but will grow back to its original size before you know it.