MH questions.......

chef jaysen

Member
So being not as rich as everyone else here i've been researching for my up and coming 175+ reef and started looking for a cheap way to do mh lights. So I went to home depot and saw the mh bulbs they have there and called up the company to see what kelvin they were. The 175 and 400 are both 4000 - 4500 k. Considering the crazy power of these lights will they not work? Is anyone using them or is this just too good to be true...Thanks
 

cliffrouse11bas

Active Member
That low of kelvin would cause a bad algae outbreak. That spectrum is in the more yellow color. The lowest I would shoot for is 6500...
 

mlm

Active Member
The spectrum of that bulb is too low. YOu want a minimum of 5500k but 6500k and up is better.
 

ryebread

Active Member
Plus the fact that the bulbs may not have any sort of UV protection = Dead Fish & Corals.
To good to be true? You betcha.
 

slothy

Active Member

Originally posted by RyeBread
Plus the fact that the bulbs may not have any sort of UV protection = Dead Fish & Corals.
To good to be true? You betcha.


always wonder, what do the fish out in the sea use to protect them from uv light ?
 

bang guy

Moderator

Originally posted by slothy
always wonder, what do the fish out in the sea use to protect them from uv light ?

I've wondered too.
As far the HD MH goes, the light will work but it will be BU^^ UGLY! My major concern is the lack of water resistance.
 

bluemarlin

Member
How about using a Home Depot ballast and good 10,000 K aquarium bulbs? At least you could save money on the ballast. Does HD sell the ballasts for these?
 

jonthefb

Active Member
being that i work at Home Depot and IN the electrical dept where you saw the bulbs, i too have had this thought running around in my head for some time and have researched it quite a bit. true the bulbs woudl work, but the color temp is horrible and woud as stated above cause horrible algae blooms, and look like crap. What i WOULD reccommend doing would be to tlak to your electrical rep about ordering in a MH ballast in whatever wattage you want cause this can range anywhere from 20-50 bucks(much cheaper than fish retail online) from advance transformer. true they will be magnetic ballasts, but for the price you cant beat em. The MH ballast kit from advance comes with teh bare bones, a plug/cord, the ballast adn the wires to run to the socket. Youd also have to special order some porcelain Mogul based sockets, unless you can find them at teh store cause most HD's dont stock them...Next youd have to look at reflectors if you get soem of the newer reflectors, you can ditch the socket idea cause soem of them have sockets already builtin, which might work a little better for you...anyways, thats jsut a start. if your comfortable working with electricity, its not to hard to build your own hood/lightign set-up.
BTW, heres a cool link about how to build a MH ligh for under a hundred bucks! not sure if i agree with it altogether, but its interestign reading material!
http://aquarium.union.rpi.edu/rpi.html
good luck
jon
 

jonthefb

Active Member
oh, with the link, click on the clown trigger or articles tab on the left hand side, then the how to make a mh lightign for under 100 bucks link
good lcuk
jon
 

chef jaysen

Member
Jon and everyone, what about the lighting units they have there. Could i use them. They are already setup for mh. Can i just buy the 30-50 dollar unit (i forget the actual price) and put in a same watt, 10k mh bulb?
 
Top