These topics are always interesting to get in to. Cars are something most everyone has a passionate opinion on. Guess I'll add my two cents.
I recently had a Ford Mustang GT. Nice car, went fast, rattled quite a bit inside, got crappy gas mileage and had no trunk space to speak of. Pain in the butt to park too with those long doors. Plus, everywhere you looked, there were a bunch of them just like mine.
I sold it to buy my current car, a VW GTI. Nice car also, very quick, very good gas mileage, lots of room, and an absolute kick in the pants to drive. Easier to park too and a lot more scarce on the road.
I've has good American vehicles and bad ones, same with the imports. I caught some flack about it at work, but it all comes down to this.
Its your car, drive what you like...