Seahorses' Light Tolerance

rykna

Active Member
Does this make sense?~I posted this another another site an wanted your opinion regarding the light situation
Brine and Submersible Lights:

My Post:
It's hard enough to make sure your horses get enough to eat, let alone your ponies. Since bbs(baby brine shrimp) are attracted to light, it occured to me that a small submersible light would make the perfect food dish for ponies.
Last night was the second bbs buffet with the light show. The adults and babies had already gathered before I turned the submersibles on. One baby even swam down and sat on the light and proceeded to slurp bbs.

Rykna,
I have to be honest with you and say I think this is a bad idea for your horses and very un-natural. You are forcing them to go to a light in order to be able to eat.
Yes, artemia are attracted to light and if you want to deprive your horses of hunting, then you could place a small light on the outside of the tank directed at the bottom yet not forcing the horses to stare into it.
I have always found that zosterae are not hard to feed at all if given the correct setup and variety of foods. They will be active and love to hunt and feed.
Many claim that zosterae will only hitch and wait until the food swims by and in many instances we have discovered that the people were keeping their horses at excessively high temps,etc, causing them stress and having to expend excess energy with increased respiration.

[hr]
Janet
Rykna,
Just understand that bright lights are not so good for horses, they live in less then clear waters where they are somewhat hidden, so their eyes are good for low light situations, not so good for bright lights.
Great thought but.

[hr]
Cheers, David
My response:
Sigh...yes, seahorses live on coastal waters that are murky. The lights I am using are not bright lights. They are tiny night time spot lights. Used for night time viewing, 4 watts at most. My intent was to gather the brine in the dense hitching post areas for easier access to dinner, instead of having them swept away in the current. I prefer to keep my tanks set up as close as I can to the seahorses' natural habitat. The pony tank has several corners filled with Chaeto and Caulerpa. I put one of the lights in the middle of these, the babies flock here just before dinner time. The other light I place in the middle of several artificial plants that are a favorite hitching posts for the adults. They to arrive right on time for dinner.
Many new born ponies do not make it past the first two days of life due to starvation. In the wild food sources are abundant, but no so in our tanks. Do to the seahorses' inefficient digestive tract, making sure your seahorse(w/all fish but seahorse are the extreme example) receives a balanced diet is essential to their longevity. After training my Kuda and Kelloggi to eat from a food dish, I began thinking of ways to do the same for ponies. Hence my idea to use the light to draw the brine into a smaller area, similar to what sharks, dolphins, and other large predators do to schools of fish. By herding them together they do not have to expend extra energy chasing after individual fish.



[hr]

My Post:
Going back to you comment about the light being too bright. I watched the ponies last night as they fed. None of them seemed bothered in the least by the lights, but that doesn't mean it does not have a bad effect on them. How many times did you parents tell you "Don't sit too close to the TV, you'll ruin you eye sight!" I considered covering the lights with Chaeto, since the brine love to hide in it.
This is my current schedule for night feeding time. When it's dinner time, I turn the feeding lamps(FL), while I soak the brine in garlic for 10 minutes. When the brine is done soaking I turn the main light off and release the brine into the tank leave the feeding lamps on for 20 minutes or so. Then I turn the FL off and all the tank lights are off for the night.
All my ponies, except the large male and a few females given to me by a friend, have been born in my tank. Given that these are CB, I would think their light tolerance would be different. But, being born CB doesn't change the physical make up of a seahorse.
Would a picture or video of the tank with the FL on be helpful to determine if the lights are too bright?

I currently disagree that the lighting would disrupt the seahorses vision and eating habits, but I would like to hear your thoughts and opinions.
~Rykna
 

bronco300

Active Member
the issue with using a bigger tank for tiny horses

i have not heard either way...but if you think about putting too much light on a coral...its possible it gets harmed from it...say putting a soft low light coral under intense light that it normal does not live in or is used to...it starts looking bad and may die....same with this possibly? what's not bright for us i'm sure is 100% different to them..shine a flashlight in directly in your eyes...you can function, but not as well with the light beam right there...true? same as them, i have no clue, but i wouldnt be surprised.
i'm sure if you sat and stared 2" away from the tv always your eyes would start doing something in a negative effect.
 

rykna

Active Member
Originally Posted by Bronco300
the issue with using a bigger tank for tiny horses

I am not concerned about the tank size silly......hmmmmm however, you have a good point there......THERE I said it!!!!
Happy
"Mr. Fancy Pants~ i.e. Luke(he's gonna cream me for this..giggle)...stands firm with his belief that ponies should not be kept in anything larger than a 10 gallon tank. So, even though....and yes, Luke, you can quote me on this
Luke's concern about tank size is very valid because of food intake...What I was asking.......before you interupted my sermon Brother Luke, is...are seahorses distressed by bright light.
 

bronco300

Active Member
haha, read the rest of my post, i commented on that too...not that they cant be in anything larger, but it gets much much harder with the food density and all that good stuff
but really, my comment to the tank size was for the pure fact of even needing this light, as the one person commented, in a certain system feeding is not a problem...but in a b igger it becomes more difficult, where you come up with this light, etcetc....if you have a 10gallon, a light wouldn't be unecessary...or in a larger tank if you have a giant pod collection like they would have in where they normally live maybe...that was my point.
 

rykna

Active Member
Originally Posted by Bronco300
haha, read the rest of my post, i commented on that too...not that they cant be in anything larger, but it gets much much harder with the food density and all that good stuff
but really, my comment to the tank size was for the pure fact of even needing this light, as the one person commented, in a certain system feeding is not a problem...but in a bigger it becomes more difficult, where you come up with this light, etcetc...that was my point..if you have a 10gallon, a light would be unecessary...or in a larger tank if you have a giant pod collection like they would have in where they normally live maybe
Very true.
Sorry couldn't resist with the badgering.
I agree 100% with you. Thanks for th input Luke
 

rays862

Member
Just my observations. I have a 60 hex with a XM 250 14K. Live rock heaped up in the middle with caves inside. The horses (northern erectus) were always hiding except at feeding time. I moved the horses to a 90 with normal output fluorescent lighting, and they are always out. On the other matter, I never kept dwarfs in more than a ten gallon tank. Less water volume = denser food stocking, thus no need for submersible light. I do use a 15W bulb at the end of my 10 gal fry tanks, so as to keep them off the surface, and naturally the BBS are attracted to the light.
 

zeke92

Active Member
what about using a small small light that isn't bright at all but will still attract the horses without bothering them whatsoever?
either way i don't think a small light will bother them too much. but as you know, i'm new to KEEPING horses, although i've been researching for over a year i've never read about this topic, so i can't say much
 

bronco300

Active Member
but how do we know what bothers and what does not without studying them long term with it...maybe put the light in a ton of cheato to pan out the light, but i'm not sure i'd do LEDs because they can be bright..or a light in general, i'd probably get a 10gallon tank
 

rays862

Member
Why do you need a light? There are no lights in the ocean, these animals hunt for their food with natural daylight. We use lights to better see them. The situation here is, that a 29 is far too large for dwarfs, unless you plan to saturate the water column with BBS everyday.
 

zeke92

Active Member
rays were just talking if it would bother them to use a light to make it easier for them to find bbs in one small area of the tank so rykna didn't have to add so much bbs to make sure the dwarfs found enough food.
i think it would be something to test and experiment with rykna.
 

bronco300

Active Member
prob i see is you cant assume all the seahorses will come eat in it...so if you do less bbs then you have less bbs floating everywhere else so those that stay away from the light start missing meals or not getting enough for the meal--if it were two seahorses you could easily tell....but when you have seahorses the size of a quarter...that will birth 10+ babies in a span of maybe even 2-3weeks....(with babies being the size of a dime)...its much harder to keep track of every single one.
 

rykna

Active Member
Originally Posted by Bronco300
prob i see is you cant assume all the seahorses will come eat in it...so if you do less bbs then you have less bbs floating everywhere else so those that stay away from the light start missing meals or not getting enough for the meal--if it were two seahorses you could easily tell....but when you have seahorses the size of a quarter...that will birth 10+ babies in a span of maybe even 2-3weeks....(with babies being the size of a dime)...its much harder to keep track of every single one.
Or take a hint from you seahorse buddy(ies),
and purchase a 5.5 gallon tank a put the ponies in there. Which I did buy one today, and will set up tonight.I decided to use the 29 for my breeding tank.
I do like the 29 tank set up, but I'm going to try a little experiment...yes..again...I've taken pictures of the ponies in the 29. In a week or so, I'm going to take pictures of the ponies in the 5.5 and compare body size, color, and over all health.
 

rays862

Member
Originally Posted by Rykna
Or take a hint from you seahorse buddy(ies),
and purchase a 5.5 gallon tank a put the ponies in there. Which I did buy one today, and will set up tonight.I decided to use the 29 for my breeding tank.
I do like the 29 tank set up, but I'm going to try a little experiment...yes..again...I've taken pictures of the ponies in the 29. In a week or so, I'm going to take pictures of the ponies in the 5.5 and compare body size, color, and over all health.

Looking forward to your results.
However, would like to see longer term study.
 

rykna

Active Member
Originally Posted by Rays862
Looking forward to your results.
However, would like to see longer term study.
Cool!!! You supply the grants, I'll do the reasearch!!!
jk But I definitely take notes and post updates
 

zeke92

Active Member
rykna this is gonna sound strange, me being a 15 year old boy, but "your my idol and when i have more money i hope to do more experiments and stuff like you.
"
 

rykna

Active Member
Originally Posted by zeke92
rykna this is gonna sound strange, me being a 15 year old boy, but "your my idol and when i have more money i hope to do more experiments and stuff like you.
"
Thank you Zeke!!!! That means a lot to me, I enjoy our hobby, and what I like best about it is inspiring/helping others to succeed.
If you do have any ideas you'd like to try out in your tanks, let me know, there are tons of ways to get a hold of tank equipment with little or no cash. For instance, I spent $30 dollars in my LFS bargin basement room.
Loot I found:
10 gallon tank
Light unit for the 10g
Submersible Lights
Coralife Light unit
2, 4 square pin bulbs
Ehiem canister
Filter Floss
and a few other odds and ends.
So when there's a will, there's a way

That's my motto

~Rykna
 

rykna

Active Member
Originally Posted by Bronco300
then what?
then what......Then What??? I'm waiting for my grant from Rays862.
 

bronco300

Active Member
Originally Posted by Rykna
then what......Then What??? I'm waiting for my grant from Rays862.


i mean what will be the results? short term 1 week studies will be nice but overall won't do much since it doesn't mean as much for success since here in the saltwater world success means years, not months even....ya know what i mean? but it sure is a good start , just wondered what the end purpose/conclusion would be from that study
 
Top