shrimp molting

fish_geek*

Member
hi all,
my cleaner started to molt about two days ago, from that time to now he has been laying on his back and all his legs look like they are tangled up.He can still move around but he can't walk Is this normal?
Thanks,
David
 

fish_geek*

Member
Here are some pictures, kinda big ,he was behind the rock at the back of tank.






I dont have the thing that mesures calcium so im not really sure but i got another cleaner shrimp and he is very active and acts normaly.
Thanks,
David
 

watson3

Active Member
But has the other one tried to molt yet? I had an arrow crab did when he was molting..The calcium level helps get the old shell off and the new one hardened...Something like that
 

teen

Active Member
you arent dosing iodine are you? iodine usually causes shrimp and inverts to molt excessively, but i guess this could also be a side effect.
 

bang guy

Moderator
Originally Posted by watson3
The calcium level helps get the old shell off and the new one hardened
I've never heard that. I don't understand how Calcium could make a difference.
 

watson3

Active Member
Calcium is one of THE most essential elements in nature required by corals, crustaceans, mollusks, coraline algae and certain other calcareous forms of macroalgae to grow. By extracting calcium from sea water, they use it to build their skeletal structures from calcium carbonate
 

teen

Active Member
Originally Posted by fish_geek*
nope no iodine
David
are you adding any supplements?
 

chipmaker

Active Member
I have kept alllkinds of shrimp for many many years and have yet to add any iodine to anay tank., They all molt and grow and spawn just fine. I view adding iodine as yet another snake oil product thats used to make money in sales and in test kits. Water changes provide all the elements needed for shrimp to molt. As for calcium it helps them grow a new shell but it does nothing in terms of helping them shed the old one. There is definately a prpboem with that shimp if its taken this long and its certianly not caused by a lack of any elements. I have yet to have a shrimp take more than a short period of time. I can setup and watch my tanks until midnight, and get up at 5 am and there will be shed pieces all over, and they are just hanigng out allowing the new skelton to harden up. It has never taken long at all to have em molt.That goes for all the typical shrimp and crabs normally kept.
 

fish_geek*

Member
I just took a closer look at the shrimp and it seems like one of his legs are broken or like bent (white in colour) and doesnt move at all, he keeps scratching it with his claws....is there anythining i can do?
The shrimp has been in this tank for about a week now and i do not add any supplements, just feed two times a day (half a cube in morning one in evening)
Thanks,
David
 

bang guy

Moderator
Originally Posted by watson3
Calcium is one of THE most essential elements in nature required by corals, crustaceans, mollusks, coraline algae and certain other calcareous forms of macroalgae to grow. By extracting calcium from sea water, they use it to build their skeletal structures from calcium carbonate
Crustacean exoskeletons are Chitin, not Calcium carbonate. There's absolutely no Calcium in Chitin.
Where did you hear their skeletal structures were Calcium carbonate?
 

bang guy

Moderator
Originally Posted by reefreak29
it is essential to have proper iodine levels for shrimp to molt
I really don't believe that's true. Iodine can force them to molt prematurely but it is in no way needed for molting.
 

teen

Active Member
Originally Posted by chipmaker
I have kept alllkinds of shrimp for many many years and have yet to add any iodine to anay tank., They all molt and grow and spawn just fine. I view adding iodine as yet another snake oil product thats used to make money in sales and in test kits. Water changes provide all the elements needed for shrimp to molt. As for calcium it helps them grow a new shell but it does nothing in terms of helping them shed the old one. There is definately a prpboem with that shimp if its taken this long and its certianly not caused by a lack of any elements. I have yet to have a shrimp take more than a short period of time. I can setup and watch my tanks until midnight, and get up at 5 am and there will be shed pieces all over, and they are just hanigng out allowing the new skelton to harden up. It has never taken long at all to have em molt.That goes for all the typical shrimp and crabs normally kept.
i wasnt suggesting adding iodine to the tank, i just know that some people add iodine to tanks thinking it will help with something; and in turn, it causes shrimps to molt irregularly. and iodine isnt just a product to just make money with no benefit, its used as an exremely effective dip for lots of corals.
 
Top