Starting to put together my list of fish

2quills

Well-Known Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sparty059 http:///forum/thread/380043/starting-to-put-together-my-list-of-fish/20#post_3306482
So I don't want anyone to think I'm disregarding any advise or information provided to me thus far. However, I see this information on a website for the Blue Hippo Tang:
 
Description: This beautiful fish is royal blue, with a black palette pattern on the side and a yellow tail. Of the thousands of fish available to the trade, this is one of the most popular of them all! It is widely distributed throughout the Central, Southern and Western Pacific, and like all fish collected from many different locations, quality varies from one collection location to another. Beware of cheap specimens. It is shy, especially when first introduced to the aquarium, and should be provided with coral, live rock, or other suitable shelter sites. This tang will lie on is side (often startling those unaware of it's behavior) if it cannot find a suitable hiding place, or when first introduced into the aquarium. This species is usually more docile than many other Surgeonfishes, and gets along great in a peaceful community or reef tank.
Recommended Tank size: Requires a 20 gallon or larger aquarium with a number of hiding places and plenty of room to swim.To keep multiple specimens, introduce the entire lot at once into the marine system.
Food and diet: In nature it feeds almost entirely on brown macroalgae and should be offered a wide a variety of foods including plenty of algae. Although Tangs will eat meaty foods along with the other fish in the aquarium, it is important that they are offered plenty of seaweed and algae. These are the foods that will strengthen their immune system, reduce aggression and improve their overall health. Offer dried seaweed tied to a rock or use a veggie clip, and feed at least 3 times per week. Sea Veggies, Seaweed Salad and Ocean Nutrition are all ideal products and are very easy to use.
Reef Compatability: Good reef fish
Level of Care: Easy
Approximate Purchase Size: Small: 1 to 2"; Medium: 2-1/4" to 3-1/4"; Large: 3-1/2" to 5"
 
It looks to me like they're implying that I can keep it no problems in a 125 gallon... however, the power blue tangs information is:
 
Description:This gorgeous fish is sky blue overall, with a yellow dorsal fin, a white anal fin, a black head and a white band behind the head. It is perhaps the most beautiful members of the genus.This fish will be shy when introduced to the aquarium and will require plenful hiding places to refuge in if threatened. A tank with a flourishing algae crop or live rock will help it adapt to the aquarium. Like most surgeonfish, this species can be aggressive toward surgeonfish tankmates once it acclimates, especially members of its own kind (keep only one per tank). Provide with plenty of swimming room, as well plenty of hiding places.
Note: We ship Powder Blue Tangs in very large bags. Because of this there is an additional $10.00 added to the shipping cost to make sure it gets to you in great shape..
Recommended Tank size: requires a 125 gallon or larger aquarium with a number of hiding places and plenty of room to swim.
Food and diet: In nature it feeds almost entirely on brown macroalgae and should be offered a wide a variety of foods including plenty of algae. Although Tangs will eat meaty foods along with the other fish in the aquarium, it is important that they are offered plenty of seaweed and algae. These are the foods that will strengthen their immune system, reduce aggression and improve their overall health. Offer dried seaweed tied to a rock or use a veggie clip, and feed at least 3 times per week. Sea Veggies, Seaweed Salad and Ocean Nutrition are all ideal products and are very easy to use.
Reef Compatability: Great reef fish. Typically fares notably better in reef aquariums than in fish only tanks.
Level of Care: Moderate
Approximate Purchase Size: Small: 1-1/2" to 2-1/2"; Medium: 2-1/2" to 3-1/2"; Large: 4" to 5-1/2"; XLarge: 6" to 7"
 
And also claims it's a bit harder to take care of than the blue hippo tang... is this just wrong?
Wow...I did a search with the ol copy and past method and it looks like there are a few sites advertising this fish with this excact same wording. Scary!
 
I agree the information for the blue hippo is not right. Sad because I think some people are doing this just to get sales.
 

meowzer

Moderator
LOL...well I have a Royal Dottyback...and sometimes it is soooo mean....I could not imagine having more than 1
 

levinjac

Active Member
I was going to get a royal dotty back when I got the gramma but the dotty back was agressive and I have a peaceful and semi aggresive mix so no dottyback for me
 

sparty059

Active Member
3 Banggai Carinalfish
2 Royal Gramma
2 clownfish – 1 Black and White Perc, and 1 Orange and White Perc
Blue Dot Jawfish
Warpaint Clown Goby
Eyelash Lawnmower Blenny
Blue Mandarin Dragonet Goby
Regal Angelfish (Or some type of Reef Safe Angelfish)
Tigertail Sea Cucumber
Sand cleaning sea star – A year or so down the road
4 Bumble Bee Snails
4 Peppermint Shrimp
8 Nassarius Snails

3 Torchus Snails

3 Atlantic Lettus Slugs

Green Dragon Eye Zoo
Eagle Eye Zoo
Green Star Polyp
Rainbow Ricordea Mushroom Polyp
Bright Yellow and Red Fountain Head Feather Dusters
Australian White Lighting Sponge – If I am feeling risky on transferring it
Tube Anemone – CAN I HAVE THIS?
The Site mention that it only needs low light, so I figured I could place it half way up and it would have enough light and the clownfish would love playing in it!

 
If I make any changes to the list I’ll let you all know, but as always, let me know if I need to remove anything or possibly add anything. I have a feeling this stock list might be overkill... if it is, let me know so I can have a price in mind of how much everything will cost.
 
 
 
Also keep in mind, I'm not going to be adding everything right away... it will be a slow process, I just need to know my list so I can get the most aggressive in there first (as suggested).
 

2quills

Well-Known Member
Id look up the requirements on the tube anemone on some other sites as well just to be sure on the light. Or maybe someone else here will know. Anemones will move around the tank anyways no matter where you put them to try and find a spot they like. Low light could still mean you need stronger than pc lights.
 
Oh and having an anemone and clowns together in a tank is no garantee that they will host. Especially with captive breed clowns.
 

cranberry

Active Member
The are non-photosynthetic and require meaty items to feed. They are not a true anemone and do not move around like one. Yes, they are mobile (mainly when uncomfortable), but the really do move very little. Their homes are tubes in the sand.
 

sparty059

Active Member
Corey- Correct. I understand that having anemone will not guarantee that they will host, I just assumed the clowns will swim in and out of it... not entirely for hosting purposes, just hoping that they like to play around with it.
 
Cranberry- So then you're implying that it's ok to get this type? You say it doesn't move around like normal ones, does it still have the flow of a normal anemone? For example will its tentacles move around or are they kind of a stiff looking anemone?
 
Everyone -- Does the update of the list look fine? I only highlighted the tube anemone because that was my biggest concern... but there are additional updates in the list.
 

meowzer

Moderator
I also have a pink tube.....mine has not moved since I put it in the tank....I feed it a couple pieces of bay scallop almost daily....
 
I don't have a pic here at work....OOHHH It's at the beginning of my video
 
https://forums.saltwaterfish.com/forum/thread/379993/video-of-my-225g
 

wangotango

Active Member
+1 on Cardinals for a "schooling" fish. A small group of Longspine or Orange-Lined would be pretty impressive.
 
Engineer gobies look a lot like eels when they're fully mature (a lot of people often confuse them for one). These might make a good alternative if you were still set on a good "eel replacement." They are burrowers so make sure your rock is placed either directly on the tank bottom, or on some kind of cushion.
 
If you want a true reef safe angel, then your best bet would be something in the Genicanthus family like the Swallowtails or Lamarck's.
 
Don't expect the clowns to host the tube anemone. They don't associate with them in the wild.
 

sparty059

Active Member
I looked at the gobies you mentioned and will probably use that to sub the eel. A school will be fine with 3 right? If not will they just mate hopefully and those will join as part of the school?
What does everyone think about the new list including the suggestion of the engineer goby?
 
Top