Originally Posted by mfp1016
I dont think any one hear is overtly trying to be hostile to you............but on the other hand you must understand how many times a lot of us have seen very similar "I've done the impossible" attitudes fail.
Also, FWIW, even its temporary, the sailfin can just kind of up and die in a small tank; I've seen it a few times when I have moved and I put some of the larger species tangs into smaller holding tanks.
But they are not impossible tanks to keep. I have kept many, many nanos 20gl and smaller for many years. This year is actually the first time I have had a reef larger than a 20gl. The only time I ever had a tank crash was in OKC when I forst started reefs and was using tap and the weekend I did a water change the city backflushed the water system and what ever was in there killed everything within an hours time. Since then I have used RO/DI and as I said, had many reefs under the 29gl with lots of coral and fish and had no problems. Just because some have failed at keeping them doesn't mean all will fail.
With regular water changes, attention to tank parameters, compatable livestock, there is no reason why a 29gl with what is in phils29bcinwa can't be kept. Though some of the LPS will quickly outgrow that tank and the sweepers will cause problems. Now if you are stating that the livestock that is in there at the moment may cause some problems, then I would have to agree. The flowerpot and torches and maybe even the clam eventually, but as far as keeping a heavily stocked 29 without it crashing, that is very possible. But it does require regular attention and even a couple of missed water changes can upset the delicate balance. nad that is what must be achieved with a nano more so than with a larger tank, a delicate balance. A didication to detail and a timely maintainance schedule with no interuptions.