There is a flaw in your thinking because the gas tax is a fair tax. It is set up as the more you drive, the more you pay for the repair of our roads. The difference b/w the gas tax and others is that the $ goes 100% to the funding of the repair... Yes you can argue that our roads won't crumble... but look at how much we use our roads... and by reducing the tax encourages people to drive more, and which requires additional maintenance. So the funding has to come from somewhere, and whynot make drivers pay the tax. Also, look at Minn Bridge Collapse, we have many other bridges around the country that need repair, also our infrastructure is 50 years old.... and needs constant repair due to age, stress, and weather erosion... So if you remove the tax, you are looking at a deficit.
The only way to reduce gas prices on our own is to use less of it, which means a nationwide effort to use less gas. Such as mass tranportation and gas conservation strategies. Basically if the American people could take a timeout on being selfish, materialistic, inpatient, too busy,etc... we could do it on our own... but this is highly unlikely.... we are unwillinging to change our patterns... The Gas Tax holiday is a bad idea... We need to produce affordable fuel effiecent cars, develop non petroleum based products, we need to use/develop alternative fuels, we need to find more domestic oil, we need to stop shipping all our oil, we need peace/ better relations in the Middle East, we need to end this war.