Originally Posted by Rylan1
All we do is throw money at problems, we don't solve the problem. And immigration is a problem in this country because of the strain it puts on our budget and social security. This is an issue that needs to be addressed, but I think the Bush Admin is taking the wrong approach. There is so much more opportunity here to make money than there is in Mexico. You can't blame them for coming over...its actually the smart thing to do. However we need to work with the mexican gov't to solve the problem. Illegal immigrants do help our economy and in many ways we are taking advantage of them.
you're very much right about the budget and social security. in addition to national security. it is so easy for an illegal alien to commit a crime in the US and flee back across the border. also, there's no way of knowing how many there are. the 'estimate' is what, 12 million? it could be double that.
I don't agree about the helping our economy part though. they are mainly helping the economy of Mexico, where most of their money goes back to. they are earning the money here, but shipping it back to their families in Mexico. further, this "they'll do the jobs that Americans won't do" is a lie. they do the jobs that Americans CAN'T do because Americans would have to pay taxes on top of the already low pay. the employers are getting off scott free because they aren't paying towards taxes or insurance, so they're able to pay illegals much less than an American worker. this savings isn't passed on to the consumer, it's passed on to the employer's bank account. the price you pay for a newly constructed house isn't going to be affected by whether it's built by US citizens or illegal aliens, because any savings is passed on to the contractor, not the buyer. so this isn't helping the US economy at all.
just like everything else, this illegal immigration is something that benefits the rich and hurts the poor and middle classes.