Butter that popcorn here we go!
I THINK/hope what our new friend means is that newly purchased live rock comes with unwanted critters. I purchased dead rock and sand because I wanted a seahorse tank clear of any possible pests...I regretted it. It took forever to seed. I enjoy live rock and sand and so far the bad hitchhikers have not been too bad. I never got the good hitchhikers but others have.
HOWEVER....his nitrate comment makes this really hard for me to make logic sense from. Because be it alive or be it dead, if it harbors nitrates (which it doesn't) it wouldn't make any difference.
Rock and sand is what your good bacteria builds on that stablizes the tank, The very opposite of what Marinebiofreak said. The food and poop from your fish and critters is ammonia..good bacteria feeds on the ammonia, but they turn that yummy ammonia into..nitrites...some other kind of good bactria that lives on nitrites start building a home in and on the rocks and sand...they reduce the yummy nitrites to nitrates, In a perfect inviroment the nitrates get reduced to a harmless gas stage. However most of the time there is more nitrate than you can shake a fist at..so we change out the nitrate infested water for clean saltwater called...drum roll....a water change. This is a natural cycle...so all we do with a critter in any fish tank large or small reduces it into nitrates eventually.
Marinebiofreak, if your tank is unstable it isn't the rock. Start another thread with the issues you have been dealing with, and I'm sure you can get some help to get things rolling along easier. Believe me it isn't the live rock and sand. Most likely the live rock is what has kept your tank alive at all. If I didn't get a chance to say it...Welcome to the site.