kjr_trig
Active Member
Originally Posted by browniebuck
http:///forum/post/3223627
I am beginning to think that ranking the recruiting classes is one of the stupidest things done in college sports. How many years did Charlie Weiss have one of the top 10 classes and...exactly what did he do with those classes???
If you want to see a real recruiter that makes the most of what they have....go to a little town called Alliance, Ohio and visit Coach Larry Kehres at D-III Mount Union College (soon to be the University of Mount Union...but will always be MUC to me). This guy picks up the scraps that aren't "good enough", aren't "big enough", aren't "fast enough", etc... to play D-I and turns them into champions year after year. You can watch one of them play in some game called the Super Bowl on Sunday...and no, he isn't the long snapper or the 4th string DE...he is one of the starting WR's for Peyton Manning and the Colts...Pierre Garcon.
You can recruit whatever you want...but if you can't coach them up and keep them eligible (see Lane Kiffin), they mean nothing. USC has been in the top 10 for how many years and have how many National Championships to show for it in the past 10-12 years?
Brownie!!! Seriously??? You use USC as an example?!?
Lets look at USC in the 8 years since Carroll took over shall we, forget before Carroll, they were below average before him...
7 straight years finishing the season in the top 5....This to me is the most impressive thing.
2 National Championships, lost a 3rd on the last play of the game, should have played in the title game last year (Sanchez year), but got screwed because everybody thought the Big 12 South was so good.
7 straight BCS games, 6 wins, 6 blowouts, one loss on the last play of the game
7 Pac 10 Titles
3 Heismann Trophy winners
1 loss out of conference in 8 years (that would be the loss to Texas on the last play of the game), and USC doesn't play cupcakes out of conference.
My favorite one...Gave THE Ohio St the worst beating they could have ever imagined under Tressel.
What exactly does a team have to do to be considered successful in your eyes?
They had a below average year last year, what do expect? They lost 12 starters to the NFL (including QB), and lost their O and D Coordinators to Washington, any other team would be thrilled with 9-4 after that.
http:///forum/post/3223627
I am beginning to think that ranking the recruiting classes is one of the stupidest things done in college sports. How many years did Charlie Weiss have one of the top 10 classes and...exactly what did he do with those classes???
If you want to see a real recruiter that makes the most of what they have....go to a little town called Alliance, Ohio and visit Coach Larry Kehres at D-III Mount Union College (soon to be the University of Mount Union...but will always be MUC to me). This guy picks up the scraps that aren't "good enough", aren't "big enough", aren't "fast enough", etc... to play D-I and turns them into champions year after year. You can watch one of them play in some game called the Super Bowl on Sunday...and no, he isn't the long snapper or the 4th string DE...he is one of the starting WR's for Peyton Manning and the Colts...Pierre Garcon.
You can recruit whatever you want...but if you can't coach them up and keep them eligible (see Lane Kiffin), they mean nothing. USC has been in the top 10 for how many years and have how many National Championships to show for it in the past 10-12 years?
Brownie!!! Seriously??? You use USC as an example?!?
Lets look at USC in the 8 years since Carroll took over shall we, forget before Carroll, they were below average before him...
7 straight years finishing the season in the top 5....This to me is the most impressive thing.
2 National Championships, lost a 3rd on the last play of the game, should have played in the title game last year (Sanchez year), but got screwed because everybody thought the Big 12 South was so good.
7 straight BCS games, 6 wins, 6 blowouts, one loss on the last play of the game
7 Pac 10 Titles
3 Heismann Trophy winners
1 loss out of conference in 8 years (that would be the loss to Texas on the last play of the game), and USC doesn't play cupcakes out of conference.
My favorite one...Gave THE Ohio St the worst beating they could have ever imagined under Tressel.
What exactly does a team have to do to be considered successful in your eyes?