how many table shrimp does it take to cycle a brand new 220 gal. tank

cranberry

Active Member

Originally Posted by beaslbob
http:///forum/post/3256107
Guy is just using secret code words only people in the hobbby over 20 years understand.
Hubby has been doing it for 53.
Using the shrimp method (or the bag-o-guts I use) can lead to a lot of different results because you really can't control the amount of ammonia you are "dosing" at any given time. The ammonia alert tag not only alerts to when it's present but also alerts you if it climbs.
The ammonia being present will also depend on what rock you are starting with. If it is dead, or mostly dead, it will be next to impossible not to see a "spike" (It's the term we use in our very own SWF sticky cycling guide... so I feel I can use it in this context accurately). At first there will be no bacteria present (or inadequate amounts) to process even the smallest amount of ammonia. Not being consumed, it will be detected on our tests. But that's as far as the accuracy goes.... you can't rely on it to give to "actual" numbers. You still have to test with a kit regularly, but it is a good "quick peak" guide. If I see colour #2... I'm changing some water.
Originally Posted by florida joe

http:///forum/post/3255968
great idea using the bag ( placing it in a good flow area can only help
)
Very important point, IMO. You don't want a pocket of elevated ammonia. You'll notice the bag is going to the left because it is directly in front of a outlet.
 

bang guy

Moderator
Originally Posted by saxman
http:///forum/post/3256098
SHEESH...gimme a break...why did i KNOW you were gonna mince words here? you need NH3, OK? even you agree...
BTW, since you like the dictionary, how bout spelling "consiter" correctly?
I agree ammonia is required to build a bacteria population and also to maintain it. I do not believe anything resembling a spike in ammonia is required. My concern isn't for the experienced hobbiest like yourself, it's for the novice that reads this thread at a later date. I don't want people believing the myth that a high ammonia level is beneficial while cycling a saltwater aquarium.
 

bang guy

Moderator
Originally Posted by Cranberry
http:///forum/post/3256138
But Bang.... the word spike is all over the care guides in the New Hobbyist section.
There are hundreds of ways to start an aquarium. I have my opinion on what works for me. Nothing I have ever written will mention purposely spiking ammonia. It will work, it's just not anything I would recommend.
 

meowzer

Moderator
I didn't use anything for my 225G...and never had any ammonia....I guess I was lucky
The 54G was a setup I bought
and the 29G, I had most ammonia in the rubbermaid, andammonia never rose above .75
 

speg

Active Member
It's my favorite when someone calls another out on spelling only to spell incorrectly themselves. It's my favorite. Makes me want to donate money to the homeless :) well... I'd at least consiter it.
 

cranberry

Active Member
Did we really need the peanut gallery? The topic was moved on.... and then there are peeps who want nothing more than to egg it on.
 
Top