Originally Posted by
ScubaDoo
Yes..any football GM relaizes that Manning would be the logical choice. You are placing your hat on just a few games. Romo has yet to prove he can win a key divisional game...he has that chance next week. He has yet to get to the playoffs...he has a good chance this year.
He did contribute to a key loss against the Giants this year...plus the team did not get the job done against the redskins.
he is playing well...but he is still not a top notch QB in my mind yet.....he has to do it a few more times for me.
Regardless, you would still be hard-pressed to find one GM that would take him over Eli Manning if given the choice....my opinion
I am holding out to see how he fairs over the next couple weeks.
He best be ready to light up the score board in two weeks against that "horrible" team.
I understand that he hasnt played enough games to be considered a top notch QB for a fact(despite how incredible he looks!) but for the life of me I still cant figure out how Eli has proven this to you??? Eli has done nothing but ride a great team that has found a way to win despite him. 3 years later and he still looks completely lost!
As far as "helping" lose the Giants game, Romo had taken exactly 2 snaps in an nfl game before, took 0% of the 1st team reps in practice that week and was thrown in at halftime of a MNF game against a defense playing GREAT. Not exactly an ideal situation, despite that he still played decent except for a few mistakes. He certainly didnt look completely lost like ELI does on a weekly basis.
As far as the Redskins game, you can hardly blame that on Romo. The correct description would be that we lost that game DESPITE how Romo played.
I cant even begin to fathom how many yards we might get against that "defense" and believe me, i use that term lightly
From what ive seen though, Romo may not have to put many points on the board. All of the Brees int's will provide us with enough points to win.