You guys talk to much so I only skimmed through the comments, so if this is a repeat... I apologize.
I want to point out first, that spanking a kid DOES NOT teach them to hit. It teaches them who the boss is. If that theory were true, then one could argue...
Don't spank the kids-They will learn to hit.
Don't cuss-They will think it's OK.
Don't smoke-Because then they will.
Basically what your saying is that kids have the "right" to act however they want, if they see it being done.
MY KIDS role is to be kids, and when they see others doing something wrong, they ARE NOT allowed to do it...Until they become adults and can judge for themselves.
And yes, if you spank your kids for something it SHOULD only have to be that one time. Pain as a consequence teaches kids... I have NEVER seen one touch a hot stove twice.
I believe that as parents, your JOB is to teach, guide, steer, and DISCIPLINE your children...If you don't, then you ARE NOT a parent, you are simply somebody who had a kid and feeds it til it grows up and moves out. Victoria, Giving advice on kids, on-line is practically impossible. You know your kids circumstances much better than we do. For example, if my 9 year old were to hide under the porch...(sounds cruel, but I would) leave him there and act like I could care less. His little antics actually worked. I have a really hard time with kids who think that they are the boss... My nephew just left, and I was SO glad to see that interrupting, controlling, manipulating, selfish, little SH*T go!! (and he DOESN'T get spanked). Once, he spent a week here... He acted like he always does, my hubby spanked him and then he was an angel... But he went home and told his mom that he never wanted to come back, because uncle Brian is mean!! And of course, she "obeyed".
AAAHH, KIDS!!!!!
I don't however think you should EVER spank your kids out of "anger". I think you should spank them as a consequence to something they've done wrong, NOT after they've done it 50 times, because by then it's YOUR fault!!